HomeMy WebLinkAboutContracts & Agreements_222-2003_CCv0001.pdf MEMORANDUM OF UNDERSTANDING
Between
THE CITY OF REDLANDS
and
THE SAN BERNARDINO PUBLIC EMPLOYEES ASSOCIATION
Representing the General Employees of the City of Redlands
July 1, 2003 - June 30, 2004
MEMORANDUM OF UNDERSTANDING
SAN BERNARDINO PUBLIC EMPLOYEES ASSOCIATION
Representing the
GENERAL EMPLOYEES UNIT OF REDLANDS
TABLE OF CONTENTS
TITLE PAGE
ARTICLE I TERM OF MEMORANDUM OF UNDERSTANDING
ARTICLE 2 PREAMBLE 3
ARTICLE 3 RECOGNITION 3
ARTICLE 4 MANAGEMENT RIGHTS 3
SALARIES, RETIREMENT AND OTHER PAY
ARTICLE 5 SALARIES 4
ARTICLE 6 RETIREMENT 4
ARTICLE 7 UNIFORM ALLOWANCE 4
ARTICLE 8 LONGEVITY PAY 5
ARTICLE 9 OVERTIME 5
ARTICLE 10 WORKING OUT OF CLASSIFICATION PAY 5
ARTICLE I I CALL BACK PAY 6
ARTICLE 12 STANDBY PAY 6
ARTICLE 13 MATRONPAY 7
ARTICLE 14 SHIFT DIFFERENTIAL 7
ARTICLE 15 SCHEDULED RECALL TO WORK 7
ARTICLE 16 TUITION REIMBURSEMENT 7
INSURANCE, LEAVE AND TIME OFF PROVISIONS
ARTICLE 17 HEALTH INSURANCE 8
ARTICLE 18 DENTAL INSURANCE 8
ARTICLE 19 VISION CARE 8
ARTICLE 20 LIFE, INSURANCE 8
ARTICLE 21 WORKERS' COMPENSATION/S.D.I. 8
ARTICLE 22 VACATION 9
ARTICLE 23 SICK, LEAVE 9
ARTICLE 24 SERE Alf EMENTLEAVE 10
ARTICLE 25 LEAVE OF ABSENCE WITHOUT PAY to
ARTICLE 26 MILITARY LEAVE I I
ARTICLE 27 PERSONAL LEAVE I I
ARTICLE 28 HOLIDAYS I I
ARTICLE 29 COMPENSATORY TIME OFF 12
ARTICLE 30 TIME OFF FOR.ASSOCIATION IZEF).'IS 12
1
DISCIPLINE, GRIEVANCE, LAYOFF PROCEDURE
ARTICLE 31 DISCIPLINARY PROCEDURES 12
ARTICLE 32 APPEAL. AND GRIEVANCE PROCEDURE 1
ARTICLE; 33 DEMOTION/NTON-DISCIPLINARY 15
ARTICLE 34 LAYOFF PROCEDURE 1
ARTICLE 35 INVESTIGATORY LNTERVIEW PROCEDURES 1
GENERAL PROVISIONS
ARTICLE 36 COPY CSE M.O.U. TO EACH EMPLOYEE 1
ARTICLE 37 PERSONNEL RULES/SALARY RESO. DIST:. 16
ARTICLE 38 PERSONNEL FILE 16
ARTICLE '39 COMMUNICATIONS 17
ARTICLE 40 UNIT MODIFICATION 17
ARTICLE 41 PREVAILING BENEFITS 17'
ARTICLE 43: MAINTENANCE OF MEMBERSHIP 17'
ARTICLE 43 USE OF BULLETIN BOARDS 18
ARTICLE 44 DIRECT DEPOSIT 18
ARTICLE 45 LEAVE TIME REPORTING 18
ARTICLE 46 WORKWEEK/STANDARD DARD TCC 1R OF DEITY 18
ARTICLE 47 PROBATION 18
ARTICLE 48 ANNIVERSARY DATE 18
.ARTICLE 49 DRIVER'S LICENSE PHYSICAL EXAMS 18
ARTICLE 50 EMPLOYMENT EXAMINATION PROCEDURES 1 `
ARTICLE 51 EXTENSION OF M.O.U. 1
.ARTICLE 52 SAVINGS CLAUSE 1
:ARTICLE 53 NO STRIDE PROVISION 1
ARTICLE 54 MEAL.PERIODS 1
ARTICLE 55 REST PERIODS 1
ARTICLE 56 CATASTROPHIC LEAVE -)o
ARTICLE 57 RIDESHARING 2
ARTICLE 58 BILINGUAL PAY 20
ARTICLE 59 PROMOTIONAL POSITIONS 20
MEMORANDUM OF UNDERSTANDING
BETWEEN
THE CITY OF REDLANDS
AND
THE GENERAL EMPLOYEES OF THE CITY OF REDLANDS
Represented by:
THE SAN BER NARDINO PUBLIC EMPLOYEES ASSOCIATION, INC.
July 1, 2003 —June 30, 2004
ARTICLE I TERM OF MEMORANDUM OF UNDERSTANDING
Except where expressly stated otherwise herein, the City and Association agree that the
provisions of this Memorandum of Understanding (M.O.U.) shall become effective on
July 1,.200') and shall expire on June 30, 2004.
ARTICLE 2 PREAMBLE
ft is the intent and purpose of this M.O.U. to set forth the understanding of the parties
reached as a result of meeting and conferring in good faith regarding, but not limited to,
matters relating to the wages, hours, mid terms and conditions of employment between
the City of Redlands (hereinafter referred to as "City") and the General Employees Unit
represented by the San Bernardino Public Employees Association (hereinafter referred to
as "Association").
ARTICLE 3 RECOGNITION
The classifications which shall be included in the General Employees unit of
representation are listed in Appendix A.
ARTICLE 4 MANAGEMENT RIGHTS
The authority of the City includes the exclusive right to deten-nine the mission of its
constituent departments, commissions and boards; set standards of service; determine the
procedures and standards of selection for employment and promotion; direct its
employees-, take disciplinary action; relieve its einployees tionn duty because of lack of
work or for other legitimate reasons', maintain the efficiency of work.; maintain the
efficiency of governmental operations; determine the methods, means and personnel by
which government operations are to be conducted; determine the content of job
classif icallons, take all necessary actions to carry out its mission in emergencies; exercise
complete control and discretion over its organization and the technology of performing its
work,
, provided, however, that the exercise and retention of such rights does not preclude
employees or their representatives from meeting and conferring over the practical
consequences that decisions on these matters may have on, wages, hours and other terms
and conditions of employment.
3
SALARIES, RETIREMENT AND 0-1-IJER PAY
ARTICLE 5 SALARIES"
Effective the first pay period after July d, 2003, salaries shall move two percent (2%),
closer to the current median of the surveyed cities for all unit classifications that are
below the median. However, in no case shall any position be moved above the median
for their classification.
During the term of this Memorandum of Understanding, the General Unit shall maintain
economic parity with any other non-Safety bargaining units in the City of Redlands.
ARTICLE TICLE 6 RETIREMENT
The City shall continue to pay to the PublicEmployees' Retirement System on behalf of
each employee covered by this agreement an amount equal to the required employee
contribution to that system provided the contribution will not exceed a total of seven
percent (7%) of regular compensation. These contributions shall, at the time o
termination, belong to the employee.
The City shall continue to include in its contract with PERS, the following provisions:
HIGHEST SINGLE YEAR
SURVIVOR CONTINUANCE
2% rr, 55 RETIREMENT FORMULA
The City shall order and pay the costs associated with an actuarial front PERS on the
2.7% ' 55 formula and the 3% @ 60 fore-mil .
ARTICLE 7 UNIFORM ALLOWANCE
The City will provide a two hundred twenty-five dollars ($225) uniform allowance in the;
form of a credit at the City's central steges for the purchase of uniforms to include;-shirts,
pants, boots,jackets, caps and patches. uniforms will be ordered during Julys and January
only, except in the case of new employees Pees and emergency situations. It is a requirement
that employees wear the designates) uniform to work, daily, The uniform is to be
presentable: Cleaning and mainten mce of unifo s shall be the responsibility of tile
employee.
Wastewater and Equipment Maintenance permanent employees will be provided uniform
rental and laundering services; at City expense, in lieu of uniform allocation. These
employees shall also receive a boot footwear allowance in the amount of one hundred
fifty dollars (S150) per year. Upon termination, of employment employees whose
urrifornis were provided to them will be required to return the uniforms to the City.
4
Animal Control Officers, Community Service Of (LSO's) and Parking Control
Officers will receive the same uniform, payable in the same manner, as those enjoyed by
the members of the Redlands Police Officers Association(RPOA).
Non-uniformed employees in this unit on payroll as ofJune I of each year and at the time
the check is issued shall receive an annual two hundred dollars ($200.00) bonus in lieu of
the uniforn-i allowance, This bonus will not be reported to PER as compensation.
ARTICLE 8 LONGEVITY PAY
Employees with twenty (20) years cumulative service with the City Shall advance to the
Step "F" on the salary resolution effective with the beginning of the pay period beginning
closest to the first day of their 21" year of service.
In the event that an employee is not at the E step when he/she is eligible for the F step, tit
the completion oft {enty(20) years of service, the employee will advan cc to the next step
in the salary range, and continue to advance based on merit until the employee reaches the
F step,
ARTICLE 9 OVERTIME
Overtime pay shall be earned at time and one-half for all hours. The employee may elect
to cam compensatory time off, at one and one-half time, in lieu of overtime pay.
Overtime iriust be paid at the time it is worked or accrued as compensatory time.
Accrued compensatory time will not be paid off in lump sum except at termination and
only for those hours on the official payroll records.
Time paid for holiday, vacation, sick leave and compensatory tirne off shall be treated as
actual hours worked for the purposes of computing overtime.
Any employee who works overtime in excess of three and one-half(31/,-) hours, provided
that employee has worked eight (8) hours in addition to the three and one-half(3!/2)hours,
will be entitled to have a meal at the expense of the City or be entitled to go home and
eat, which will be at the discretion of the supervisor in charge. The City will establish an
account at a local restaurant for use by employees working on emergency overtime.
ARTICLE 10 WORKING OUT OF CLASSIFICATION PAY
Whenever the needs of the City require an employee to temporarily perforin the duties of
a higher classification than that in which the employee is currently employed, said;
employee shall be entitled to receive out of classification pay f'or thea period of time that:
the employee works out of classification. Out of classification pay shall be at as flat rate
offive-percent (5%) of base salary.
In order to receive out of classification pay the following provisions must occur:
5
a, The name of the employee who is absent must be noted on the employee's
timeshect prior to out of classification pay being authorized.
b� A vacancy or absence must exist for out of classification pay to be paid.
c: The employee receiving out of classification pay must perform essentially
all of the functions of the higher classification in order to receive
compensation.
d. The employee shall meet the minimum qualifications for the higher
classification in order to be eligible for out of classification pay.
Working out of classification pay for special assignments will only be authorized upon
recommendation to the City Manager by the Department Head and will require a Payroll
Transaction Form with supporting docurnentation justifying the special assignment,
Employees perforri-ring in a capacity beyond the normal scope of their duties, and with
increased and direct responsibility and personal liability for City operations shall be
eligible for Special Assignment Pay. Special Assignment Pay shall be at a flat rate not to
exceed ten percent (10%) of base salary, Special Assignment Pay will only be authorized
upon Department Head recommendation, Administrative Services Director concurrence
and City Manager approval,
ARTICLE 11 CALL BACK PAY
Call back time will be reimbursed based on a minimum two (2) hour block at time and
one-half, with the exception that employees will be reimbursed based on a rainimilm
three-hour block at time and one-half if the call back is between the hours of 12:00 p-in.
and 7:00 a.m. Any employee who is unable to respond within thirty (30) minutes may be
eliminated from the standby rotation.
An employee working a continuous call back of at least four (4) hours that ends v.,ithin
eight (8) hours of the employee's regular job starting titne is not required to report to duty
at the employee's regularly scheduled time. When an employee has worked at least two
(2) hours during the, eight (8) hours prior to the commencement of the regular work
Schedule, the employee shall automatically report to duty on the employee's regularly
scheduled shift immediately corarnencing ten (10) hours after the end of the call-back
assignment.
ARTICLE 12 STANDBY PAY
Employees in the General Employees unit of representation assigned to standby duty shall
receive one t1 hour of pay at straight time for standby duty on a week day and four (4)
Hours of straight time pay for standby duty on a regularly scheduled day off, weekend day
or holiday.
6
In order to qualify for standby pay employees must:
I: Be required to be near a telephone at all times or carry a pager,
Be able to report to the worksite within thirty(30) minutes; and,
Not consume alcoholic beverages or any other debilitating drug while on standby's
ARTICLE 13 M TRO PAY
Female Police Customer Set-vice Representatives that report directly to the, Police
Records Supervisor and the police Records Supervisor shall receive a 2.5% salary
differential in recognition of the tact that they may be required to perform matron duties.
ARTICLE 14 SHIFT DIFFERENTIAL
The City agrees to provide a five-percent (5%) shift differential to those employees who
work one-half of their regularly scheduled shut after 7,00 p.m. not to include overtime
special assignments, emergency hours, etc. worked after 7:00 p.m. The shift differential
shall apply to the frill regularly scheduled shift.
ARTICLE 15 SCHEDULED RECALL TO WORK
The City agrees that when employees of the Municipal Utilities Department are recalled:
or scheduled to return to work for water system installation or a maintenance project
between the hours of 12 midnight and 4:00 a.m.} said employees shall receive time and
one-half for all hours worked. Employees performing in this capacity shall automatically
report to duty on their regularly scheduled shift immediately after a ten (10) hour rest
period has occurred from the ending time of the scheduled or recall work assignment.
ARTICLE 16 TUITION' REIMBURSEMENT
The City agrees to pay one hundred percent (100%) reimbursement for tuition and hooks
for job related courses either directed or approved by the department head. The course
must be satisfactorily completed with a minimum grade of" "or equivalent.
During the term of this Memorandum of Understanding, the, City and the Association
shall develop a program, subject to Council adoption; for a centralized, standardized
tuition<reimb trsentent program,
INSURANCE, LEAVE AND TIME OFF PROVISIONS
ARTICLE 17 HEALTH INSURANCE
A: The City shall contribute the entire monthly premium for employees in the unit
and their eligible dependents under the public Eniployce Retirement. System
(PERS).
B. The City agrees to provide a stipend on a monthly basis for those employees with
alternative medical coverage vvho Capt for the stipend in lieu of the medical;
insurance benefit. The rate of stipend will be based on the following scale;
0 - 19 employees participating $50 per month
2 4 employees participating 100 per month
25 + employees participating 150 per month
The initial evaluation to determine stipend amorm will be thirty(3 0) days from
the date the M.O.U. is signed, and will be re-evaluated every quarter,
ARTICLE 18 DENTAL INSURANCE
The City agrees to pay the fullmonthlyprep-Juin for dental insurance under either the
City's self-insured dental plan or Denti-Care dental plana for each employee in the unit
and all eligible dependents,
The City agrees to explore potential insurance changes or alternatives, including full
insurance and increasing 'maximum insurance cap provided there is no additional cast to
the Cite for such potential insurance changes.
ARTICLE lid VISION CARE
The City agrees to reimburse each employee in the unit up to one hundred-sixty dollars
IS160 evera� fiscal year for the purchase of frames and lenses or contact lenses and the:
coast of eye examinations for the employee and/or his/her dependent.:
ARTICLE 20 LIFE INSURANCE
The City shall contribute the monthly premium for: a life: insurance policy in the amount
often thousand dollars (S10,000) for all employees in the fruit:
ARTICLE LE 21 WORKER'S C `tib'1PE.NAT1C►'iDISr BILITY INSURANCE
The City agrees to provide City paid State Disability Insurance coverage to all employee
in,the unit.
Sick leave or compensatory time may be used to supplement a Worker's Compensation or
State Disability Insurance check, not to exceed the employee's regular rate of pay. Prior
to use of accrued sick leave or compensatory time for this purpose, the State Disability
Insurance check stub must be SUIN'llitted to the Payroll Supervisor.
ARTICLE 22 VACATION
The vacation accrual for employees in the unit shall be as follows:
1 5 years of service 80 hours
6 7 years of service 120 hours
8 9 years of service 128 hours
10 - I I years of service 1.36 hours
12 - 13 years of service 144 hours
14 - 16 years of service 152 hours
16 - 20 years of service 160 hours
21 years of service 168 hours
22 years of service 176 hours
23 years of set-vice 184 hours
24 years of service 192 hours
25+ years of service 200 hours
Effective January 1, 2004, the maximum vacation accrual shall be three (3) years. In
Novernber of each calendar year all vacation hours in excess of three (3) years accrual
will be paid off at the employee's current hourly rate, provided that one-half of the yearly
accrual has been used during the year under consideration.
ARTICLE 23 SICK LEAVE
AAC CURAL: Sick leave shall be accrued on an hourly basis at the rate of eight
(8) hours per calendar month of service,
13, USE: Employees may use up to half of their annual sick leave accrual, forty-
eight (48) hours, to care for ill farnily rnembers.
CBUY BACK: In November of each calendar year, each employee in the unit may
elect to be paid at his/her current hourly rate for each sick leave day.accumulated
during the preceding calendar year in excess of six (6) sick leave days. A total of
one fl) year's accumulation, ninety-six (96) hours, must be on the books prior to
any compensation being paid. Employees in the unit may also choose to
aCCUMUlate all sick leave days, from calendar year to calendar year, to an
unlimited amount.
Ds AT SEPARATION OF SERVICE: Upon separation of service with the City,
employees with ten (10) or more years continuous service will be eligible to cash
i I it unusedsick leave at the following formula:
9
10 - 15 years service.......2 %
16 20 years service.. .35%
21+ years seriice... ... 0%
Employees electing this option shall be responsible for'any and all future medical
insurance premiums.
E; UP01\1 SERVICE RETIREMENT In lieu of the above benefit, upon service
retirement under the PERS retirement plan, employees in the unit may elect to
have all remaining sick leave accrued at the time of retirerrrent converted to cash.
value at their final rate of pay, and apply such cash value to applicable premiums
payable under the City's medical insurance program for the employee and the-
employee's eligible dependents until the cash value is exhausted. In the event that
the employee dies prior to exhaustion of the cash value of said benefits, the
remaining cash value may be applied toward the premiums of covered dependents
until exhausted, subject to the conditions and limitations of the applicable
insurance policy': However, upon completion of twenty (20) cuillulative year:
service, at the employee's option he/she may elect fully paid medical insurance for
employee and eligible dependents, under the City's medical insurance program;
upon service retirement under the PERS retirement medical insurance plant; it, lien
of any type of sick leave buy back.
ARTICLE 24 BEREAVEMENT LEVE
In the event of the death in the immediate f~amily, an eligible employee will be
compensated with four (4) days paid leave. In addition, eligible employees may be
allowed to use accrued sick leave with full pay not to exceed three (3) dads. Immediate
family shall be defiried as the following relatives to either the eniployce or spouse
Spouse, child (including foster child: or ward of the court), parent, ;grandparent, brother,.
and sister. The definition of immediate family will also include the aunt and uncle cit"the
employee only. Bereavement leave may also be used for the significant other of tile
employee provided the employee shows proof of cohabitation.
ARTICLE 25 LENT::OF ABSENCE WITHO T PAY
If an employee takes more than, fiv°c: ( ) accumulated days of leave without pay ill
calendar year, commencing at the beginning of the sixth (6th) day of leave without pa
and any clay of leave without pay 'thereafter during the calendar year; sick leave and
vacation accruals will be adjusted proportionately to climinate benefit accruals for ally.
day,an, employee is on leave without pay status.
10
ARTICLE 26 MILITARY LEAVE
Military leave shall be granted in accordance with the provisions of State and Federal
law. The department head may request copies of the employee's official military orders.
ARTICLE 27 PERSONAL LEAVE
Each employee in the unit may use up to a maximum of one day of accrued sick leave per
year for personal leave, subject to advance supervisor approval.
ARTICILE 28 HOLIDAYS
The holidays which will be honored for employees in the unit will include the following,
along withany additional day as designated by action of the City Couricil:
New Year's Day(January 1)
Martin Luther King Day(Third Monday in January)
President's Day(Third Monday in February)
Memorial Day(Last Monday in May)
Independence May(July 4)
LaborDay(First Monday in. September)
Columbus Day(Second Monday in October)
Veteran's Day(November 11)
Thanksgiving Day
Friday after Thanksgiving Day
Christmas Day(December 25)
Two (2)Floating Holidays
Twenty(20) Hours Additional Floating Holidays, Effective January 1, 2004
Note- Solely for the term of this agreement, employees shall receive a reinstatement of
hours for Labor Day, Columbus Day and Veterans Day. The reinstatement shall be
added to accruals for compensatory time, and shall not exceed the amount of time used by
each employee.
If the holiday falls on Saturday, Friday shall be designated as the holiday and if tile
holiday falls on Sunday, Monday shall be designated as the holiday. Christmas Eve Day
shall be observed as a holiday when Christmas Day falls oil Tuesday, Wednesday,
Thursday, or Friday.
If a scheduled holiday falls on an employeCs regular day off, the employee shall be
compensated for one day of holiday compensation at time and one half Employees
should not be scheduled to work both the designated holiday and the actual holiday.
lJoliday pay shall be compensated in, accordance with tile employee's standard work
schedule.
Employees in the unit shall not be allowed to carry floating holidays over from one
calendar year to the=next. Holidays not taken by December 31" of any given year will be
forfeited.
The AX, SmileyPublic Library will be closed on the Saturday following Thanksgiving
Day.
ARTICLE 29 COMPENSATORY TIME OFF
CTO shall accrue at the rate of one and one-half (1-1/2) hours for each overtime hour
worked in accordance with the Fair Labor Standards Act. CTO shall not accumulate in
excess of one hundred twenty (120) hours at any given time. Use of compensatory time-
off earned shall be granted so that it does not unduly disrupt the operations of the City.
Terminating employees shall be compensated for accrued compensatory hours.
ARTICLE 30 TIME OFF FOR ASSOCIATION REPRESENTATIVES
The Association may designate up to fourteen (14) representatives to attend Association
meetings on City time, provided that no designated employee shall be released for more
than one (1) hour per week. The President of the Redlands BPEA chapter shall be
released for up to two (2) hours per week to attend to Association business. This time
shall be in addition to meetings with the City Manager, Administrative Services or City
Council members. The time must be scheduled in advance and the supervisor must be
notified,
DISCI'PLINE, GRIEVANCE, LAYOFF PROCEDURES
ARTICLE 31 DISCIPLINARY PROCEDURES
No employee shall be disciplined without cause. Disciplinary action shall be defined to
include, oral warnings, written reprimands, suspensions, demotions, reduction in pay and
discharge. Oral and written reprimands may be initiated at the supervisor/division
I
manager level, Disciplinary action more serious than a written reprimand must be
initiated at the Department Head level.
A. Notice of Proposed Action.
Whenever an employee is to be discharged, suspended (for more, than five (5)
days), demoted, or reduced in step, for disciplinary purposes, written notice of at
least five (5) working days of the proposed disciplinary action shall be given
before such action is to be taken and must include:
t) Notice of proposed action;
(2) Reasons for proposed action;
(3) A copy of charges stating specific incidents or specific courses of conduct,
e.g. as evidenced by work performance evaluations, and a copy of the
12
written materials upon which the decision to take proposed disciplinary
action is based; and
(4) A notice to the employee ofthe right to respond in writing or orally\,vithin
the five (5) working day period.
In the case of a suspension of five (5) days or less, the foregoing procedures shall
Z7�
be afforded the employee either before or during the suspension, or within a
reasonable time thereafter.
B. Limitations and Exceptions:
(1) Oral notice is insufficient as full notice to an employee and may be given
only as the initial notice in extraordinary circumstances which call for
immediate action.
(2) Prior written notice is required in each case, unless provided otherwise
herein, regardless of seriousness unless extraordinary circumstances are
involved.
(3) Employees may be suspended without prior written notice in extraordinary
circumstances when it is essential to avert harm to the public, other
employees, or to avert serious disruption of goverm-nental business. The
appointing authority may schedule an employee for vacation or holiday
leave as the circumstances may warrant. Extraordinary circumstances
include but are not limited to situations involving misappropriation of
public fund or property; working while under the influence of liquor or
intoxicating drugs; open insubordination; commission of a crime involving
moral turpitude punishable by imprisonment for six (6) months or more-,
and. disruption of City business through willful misconduct (altercations,
etc.)
(4) Oral notice is insufficient as full notice for proposed disciplinary action.
In extraordinary circumstances when immediate suspension, demotion,
removal, or reduction in step is warranted, initial notice may be given
orally. The employee should be told when the initial action is taken what
the reasons for the actions are and, in addition, the employee will have an
opportunity to respond in writing and/or orally to those charges. The
written charges in the case of an immediate disciplinary action must be
prepared as soon as possible and normally within a day or two (2) of the
initial oral notice. Employees wishing to appeal disc ifilinar.y actions may
do so in accordance with Article 32.
In general, under City procedures, probationary employees and other non-perinarient
regular employees are not entitled to notice and a hearing unless the causes for
termination are based upon charges involving a person's good name, reputation, honor or
integrity. In such cases, an employee shall be entitled only to minimal due process rights
as required by applicable law.
13
ARTICLE 32 APPEAL AND GRIEVANCE PROCEDURE
I DEFINED: A grievance is an alleged violation of the Personnel Rules and
Regulations, this M.O.U. or written City Policy.
PROCEDURE:
a, Informal Grievance Procedure: The grievant and the City's representative shall
make every effort to resolve the grievance, at the lowest level of supervision.
Thus, the grievant shall attempt to discuss the grievance with the immediate
supervisor before resorting to the Forinal Grievance Procedure below. However,
if the grievant is unable to resolve the grievance informally before the time period
for filing a Formal Grievance expires (10 working days from the date the,
grievance allegedly occurred), the grievant must proceed to the Forinal Grievance
Procedure in accordance with the time limits therein or he/she will have -waived
the right to proceed in the Formal Grievance Procedure.
bFormal Grievance Procedure:
I, First Level of Review: The formal grievance shall be presented in writing to
his/her supervisor within ten (10) working days from the alleged occurrence of the
violation. The written grievance shall contain the following inforination.
a. Name of grievant and job title,
b� Department/Section;
C. Clear and concise statement of the nature of tile grievance including the
circumstances and dates involved;
& The specific provision(s) of the M.O.U., City Policy or Personnel rules
alleged to have been violated,
e. Requested remedy
.-
f. Name of the grievant's Labor Representative, if anv-
�I
9- Date and signature of the grievant or Labor Representative.
1"he supervisor shall render a decision and comments in writing and return them to the
grievant within ten (10) working days after receiving the written grievance, If the
C11
grievant does not agree with his supervisor's decision or if no answer has been received
within the specified time period, the grievant shall present the grievance in writing to the
Department Head or his designee within live(5) days of the date the supervisor's decision
is rendered or should have been rendered pursuant to the specified,time period.
2, Second Level -j- ,)e tarn-neat Head Review- The Department Head or his designee
shall discuss, ulion request, the grievance with the grievant, tile grievant's representative
if any, and with other appropriate persons. The Department Head or designeeshall render
his decision and comments in writing and return them to the grievant within ten (10)
working days after receiving the for written grievance. Ifthe grievant does not agree
with the decision reached or if no answer has been received within the specified tiryle
14
period, the grievant may appeal the grievance to the next level of the grievalice procedure.
11-�
In order to do so, the grievant must submit the grievance to the Personnel Director, along
with a written request that the grievance be considered at the Third Level, within ten (10)
working days of the date the Department Head's decision is rendered, or should have
been rendered, pursuant to the specified time period.
1 Third Level -- City Manage , If the grievance is submitted to the City Manager
,for review and settlement, the City Manager may elect the methods lie/she considers
appropriate for the study of the issues and shall render a written decision to the parties
within ten (10) working days of receipt of the grievance.
4. Fourth Level -- Advisory Mediation. If the grievance has not been resolved after
completion of the third level above, either the Association or the City may request non-
binding mediation through the State of California, Department of Industrial Relations
Mediation and, Conciliation Scn)ice. This mediation shall be provided by the state at no
cost to either the City or the employee.
5. Fifth Level — City Council- If the grievance is not adjusted to the satisfaction of
the employee under the procedures set forth in the forgoing sections, the ernployee or
his/her designated representative, if any, within ten (101 working days after the
completion of the last step under the third level above, shalt submit a written request to
the City Council or their designee, for a hearing before the City Council or their designee.
Such request, along with a copy of the record of the grievance developed to that point,
shall be transmitted to the City Council or designee within ten (10) working days after
receipt of such request for a hearing. The City Council shall render their decision within
ten (10) working days of the hearing. The decision of the City Council shall be final and
binding.
ARTICLE 33 DEMOTIONNON-DISCIPLINARY
Regular employees who are demoted due to layoff or other non-disciplinary reasons will
be required to serve a new probationary period in the lower classification, provided they
have not held regular Status in the lower classification previously. While serving this ne-,v
probationary period, the employee will retain due process rights and cannot be disciplined
or terminated firorti City service without due process.
NRTICLE 34
LA `OFF PROC EDURE
All regular employees whose positions have been eliminated shall be allowed to exercise
then- options, based on seniority, to displace an employee (bump) into the same or ally
one of thejunior classifications within thejob groupings (see Appendix B) for which they
quality or into a previously held classificationwith the City of Redlands. The employee
must meet the nitnimum qualifications for the position bumped. Employees Must UtihZC
the option which places them in the highest available position,
15
ARTICLE 35 INVESTIGATORY INTERVIEW PROCEDURES
Prior to any investigatory interview or consultation between all employee and the
Department Head or City Manager, that could, reasonably be construed to result in
disciplinary action against the employee, the employee shall be given notice of the
interview or consultation as soon as reasonable practical, and shall be advised of his or
her right to representation under this section-, and upon request shall be afforded all
opportunity to contact and consult privately with a representative of the Association. If
requested, the employee may have all Association representative present during any such
investigatory interview or consultation, and, to the extent practicable, such interviews or
consultations shall be conducted during all employee's working hours, Only those
persons reasonably necessary to the conduct of the interview shall be present.
The employee or the: City may elect to record any such investigatory inter-view or
consultation, unless the parties mutual] agree not to record such interview or
y
consultation; how -ver, in the event the City elects to record such an interview or
consultation, it shall upon request provide the employee with a copy of said recording.
The cost of providing a copy of the recording to the employee shall be home by the
employee.
GENERAL PROVISIONS
ARTICLE 36 COPY OF M.O.U. TO EACH EMPLOYEE
The City will provide each employee in the unit with a copy of this M.O.U. within sixty
(6 0)days of execution,
ARTICLE 37 RULES, REGULATIONS AND RESOLUTIONS
'File City agrees to review annually with the Association major changes in the Personnel
Rules and. Regulations and to make available copies of the rules and regulations to all
employees. Salary resolutions shall be furnished to the San Bernardino Public Employees
Association and all representatives.
ARTICLE 38 PERSONNEL FILE
No material which can reasonably be construed, interpreted, or acknowledged to be
derogatory shall be placed in all employee's personnel file unless the employee has been
allowed to read such material and respond to it, in writing, which response will also be
placed in the personnel file.
Any employee, upon request, shall have access to his/her personnel file, and shall have
the right of reproduction, at cost, of his/her personnel file in full or in part. No portion of
all employee's personnel file shall be transmitted to anyone other than the City Manager,,
Personnel Director, Department Head, Risk Management Administrators, or by Court
16
subpoena. The employee is to be notified at the time of the request that the Hilorniation
has been transmitted and to whom it was sent,
ARTICLE 39 COMMUNICATIONS
The City and, the Association shall work together in the interest of maintaining, and
nuproving efficiency in all municipal operations and conservation of materials, supplies,
and equipment, and for the improvement in quality of workmanship and service to the
public=
The City and, the Association consider themselves inutually responsible to improve
communications between management anti employees and will use their best endeavors
in establishing and maintaining effective communication channels,
ARTICLE 40 UNIT MODIFICATION
It is understood that this M.O.U. shall constitute a bar to any petition or request for
decertification of the Association as the formally recognized employee organization in the
General Employees unit of representation at any time prior to the expiration date of this
M.0,U.
In addition, no petitions for unit modification of the General Employees unit will be
accepted by the City without the express agreement of the Association.
The provisions of this Article shall not be applicable where precluded by law. The
Association, its successors and assigns, shall indemnify, defend and hold harmless, the
City, including its agents and employees, against any claims, suite or actions made or
brought against the City, including its agents and employees, for any expenses, losses or
damages incurred by the City, including its agents and employees, on account of the
provisions of this article.
ARTICLE 41 PREVAILINNG BETNEFITS
All benefits, privileges, and working conditions enjoyed by the employees at the present
time, which are not included in this agreement, shall remain in full force, unchanged and
unaffected in any manner, during the term of this agreement unless changed by mutual
consent.
ARTICLE 42 MAINTENANCE OF MEMBERSHIP
All employee members of SBPFA shall remain as members in. good standing of said
Association for the duration of this M.O.U. except as set fort-li below:
During the period from March I through March 31 of each year, any Association.member
I
who has been a member for at least one (1) year, may voluntarily withdraw from
Association membership.
17
ARTICLE 43 USE OF BULLETIN BOARDS/MAIL,
The City agrees that SBPEA may utilize bulletin board space in designated areas upon
mutuala � a C
greernent with the, City. SBPEA, will provide bulletin boards, The City gr es
to allow the use of inter-departmental mail for distribution of SI PE materials to
SBPEA representatives,only.
ARTICLE 44 DIRECT DEPOSIT
Direct deposit of employee paychecks will be available to employees in this unit.
ARTICLE 45 LEAVE TIME REPORTING
Leave time may be used and reported in increments of fifteen (i 5) minutes.
ARTICLE 46 WORKWEEK/STANDARD TOUR OF DUTY
The standard tour of duty represents the time that all employee is regularly scheduled to
work. The department head shall establish the actual number of hours which comprise
the standard tour of duty for each position. Any proposed change shall be communicated
to the employees and Association at least two (2) weeks prior to the proposed change
being implemented unless mutually agreed upon between the employee and supeRisor. If
requestedby the Association, the parties shall expeditiously meet and confer regarding
such change.
ARTICLE 47 PROBATION
The probationary period including promotional appointments shall be for a period of six
(6) months unless extended by the recommendation of the department head. The
probationary period for Public Safety Dispatchers shall be twelve (1 2) months.
ARTICLE 48 ANNIVERSARY DATE
For those employees hired after July 1, 1990, the "anniversary date" shall be the (lay of
the month in which the employee completes six (6) months of employnient, When all
employee receives a promotion. after July 1, 1990, the new anniversary date shall be the
day of the month in which the employee completes six (6) months of employment in tile
new classification. When a salary increase is granted, it shall be effective on the
beginning of the pay period falling Closest to the day of the month the eniployce Nvas hired
or promoted.
ARTICLE 49 DRI'VER'S LICENSE PHYSICAL EXAMINATIONS
The City will pay for the required phVsical examination for employees required by their
job classification to maintain Class A or Class B< driver's licenses, Time spent
participating in the required physical examination will be considered as tinle worked.
18
t RTICLE 50 EMPLOYMENT EXAMINATION PROCEDURES
The examination procedure for all City jabs will be as established by the Cite and
Association.
ARTICLE 51 EXTENSION OF M C .I
The City agrees that if a successor M 0.11. has not been reached by l.':00 a.m. (midnight)
ora the expiration date, each calendar year, the terms and conditions of the existing
M,C ,U. shall be extended sig (6) months or until a successor M.O.U. is adopted,,
whichever-occurs sooner.
ARTICLE 52 SAVINGS CLAUSE
If any provision of this C.O.U., or the application of any provision, should be rendered-
invalid by court or legislative action, the remaining portions of this Agreement shall
remain in hill force and effect:.
ARTICLE 53 NO STRIKE E PROVISI N
It is understood and agreed that the service performed by city employees included in this
M.O.U. are essential to the public's health, safety, and welfare. Therefore, the
Association agrees that it will not authorize, instigate, aid, condone, or engage in ally
strife, work stoppage, or other action of the City. In the event of a violation of this
section, the;Association agrees to take affirmative steps with the employees concerned to
bring abort an in-miediate resumption of normal work. Should there be a violation of this
section, there shall be no discussion or negotiations regarding the difference or dispute
during the existence ofsuch violation or before normal work has been. resumed. The City
reserves the right to terminate any employee who instigates or engages in any strife 01-
work
rwork stoppage which interrupts or interferes with,the operation of the City.
ARTICLE 54 MEAL PERIODS
`I`he.City agrees to the following: Employees shall;be entitled to a meal period which shall
not be less than thirty ( minutes or greater than sixty (60) nunotes. Every effort will
be, made to'schedule the meal period during the middle of shift, when possible,.
ARTICLE 55 REST PERIODS
The City agrees to thefollowing.illowing. E loyees shall be entitle to two ) daily rest periods
ten (Its) to Fifteen (15) minutes in duration which insofar its practical shall be in the,
middle of each 'work period. The, rest periods shall be considered as time worked,
Employees required to work beyond their regular tour of duty shall be granted a ten (10
minute rest,period for each two (2) hours of work.
1
The Association understands and agrees to the following: In regards to break periods, the
following scenarios should not occur:
Combining tN,,,o daily breaks into one 20-30 minute break-.
"Banking"breaks from day to day.
"Saving" break time in order to extend lunch periods or shorten the workday.
Payment of compensatory time off or overtime for"unused"breaks.
ARTICLE 56 CATASTOPHIC LEAVE
Employees are eligible for catastrophic leave in accordance with the City's Catastrophic
Leave Policy.
ARTICLE 57 RIDESHARfNG
All employees are eligible for participation in the City's ridesharing program.
Participation in the program is voluntary and shall be in full compliance of Redlands
Ridesharing Program Policy. Approved participants shall receive either One Dollar
Sixty Five Cents ($1.65) for each rideshare day OR fifteen (15) minutes of accrued
compensatory time off for each rideshare day. The cash bonus shall be paid in November
of each year. Ridesharing shall be reported on individual employee timesheets..
The program shall be monitored by the Program Coordinator. Participants in violation of
the Ridesharing Policy, including falsification of reporting, shall be permanently
dismissed from the program and subject to disciplinary action.
ARTICLE 58 BILINGUAL PAY
Employees are eligible for bilingual pay in accordance with the City's Bilingual Pay
Program, and upon approval by the Department Head and City Manager, Authorized
employees shall receive additional compensation in the amount of Sixty Five Dollars
($65)per month.
ARTICLE 59 PROMOTIONAL POSITIONS
The City may seek only promotional candidates to fill available positions. In this case,
distribution of job announcernents shall be limited to internal sources. Promotional
candidates shall follow the procedures identified in the City's Personnel Rules and
Regulations. Employees appointed to promotional positions shall complete a probationary
period in accordance with the City's Personnel Rules and Regulations.
Employees appointed to a prornotional position shall receive the nearest highest mouthlY
s a]ar,
y which is at least five percent (5%) higher than the employee's previous base Salary
but in no case more than the top step of the new salary range.
20
21
MEMORANDUM OF UNDERSTANDING
SIDE LETTERS
It is agreed and understood that the following side letter is not sLlbject to the grievance
procedure:
A committee consisting of General unit employees and the City Manager, or his designee,
I
shall be established with the purpose of enhancing operational efficiency and financial
accountability.
22
SAN BERN RDI O PUBLIC EMPLOYEES ASSOCIATION
Laine Cra-i-g Date
SBPEA
w�
i Br
r
a
kiss 'nag-,anent Tech.
nor n Baas
o Waste True' ver`
Joe �c tt
,, Dior WeIdc
Sr. x ccoun i g"recti.
ete c ssist nt
Mike ,:est
Concrete Worker
JUX
'tic. Garcia _
Water Distribution Operator
CITY Y DLAND
e
.art (" asey") Haws, Mayor Date
`C"`
y ter
APPENDIX A
C1,ASSIFICATIONS INCLUDED IN 'HEC. EN RAL EMPLOYEES UNIT
Accounting Teelmicianl/11
Administrative Assistant VII
Administrative Secretary
Animal Control Officer
Animal Control Supervisor
Asphalt Worker
Building Inspector 1/11
Building Maintenance Worker
Building Permit'technician,
Business License Inspector
Cemetery Caretaker 1/11
Cemetery Services Assistant
Code Enforcement Officer
Community Services Officer/Dispatcher 1/11
Concrete Worker
Crime Analyst
Cross Connection Control Inspector
Electrician
Equipment Operator
Equipment Maintenance Administrative Assistant
Fire Mechanic
Forensic Services Supervisor
Geographic Information Systems Technician
Grounds Maintenance Worker 1/11
Housing Technician
Human 'Resources Assistant
Hut-nan Resources Technician
ID and Property Technician
Industrial Waste inspector
Junior Engineer
Kennel Attendant
Laboratory Technician 11/11
Library Clerk
Library Information Systems Technician
Library Specialist 1/11
Line Maintenance Worker
Maintenance Custodian
Maintenance Worker
Mechanic Assistant
Mechanic F11
MIS Support Technician
Park Maintenance Mechanic
24
Parking Citation Technician
Plant :'Mechanic Ulf
Police Customer tomer Service Representative
Police Parking Control Officer
Police Records s Sup rvisor
Public Information Specialist
Purchasin- assistant
Purchasing Supervisor
Recreation Program Coordinator
Regulatory Corriplian e Officer
Resident Construction Inspector
Risk Management Technician
Senior-Accounting Technician
Senior Administrative Assistant
Senior Asphalt Worker
Senior Building Maintenance Worker
Senior Cemetery Caretaker
Senior Cade Enforcement Officer
Senior CornmunicatiOTIS Specialist
Senior Concrete Worker
Senior Equipment Operator/Landfill
Senior Equipment [Operator/Water
Senior Grounds Maintenance Worker 1/11
Senior Information Systems Technician
Senior Line Maintenance Worker
Senior Mechanic
Senior Recreation Program Coordinator
Senior Sign and Faint Worker
Senior-Solid Waste Truck Driver
Senior Storekeeper
Senior Street Maintenance Worker
Senior Tree Trimmer
Senior Water Meter Reader
Senior Water Service Worker
Senior"Welder
Sign and faint Worker
Solid Waste Collector
Solid Waste Customer Services Representative
Solid Waste Rome Supervisor
Solid Waste Truck Driver
Storekeeper
Street Sweeper Operator
Supervising Laborarory Technician
Traffic Signal Technician 1/11
Tree Trimmer t/11
Utilities Database Technician
Utility Billing Supervisor
Video Production Technician
Wastewater Treatment Operator 1/11/111/1V
Water Distribution Supervisor
Water Line/Fire Specialist
Water Meter Reader
Water Production Maintenance Supervisor
Water Production Plant Supervisor
Water Quality Control Officer
Water Quality Technician 1111
Water Service Worker III
Water Treatment Operator IFIIFIV
Welder
Worker's Compensation Technician
26
APPENDIX B
LAYOFF JOB GROUPINGS
(PER ARTICLE 34)
36 Library Clerk
38 Administrative Assistant 1
3 Police Parking Control Officer
39 Storekeeper
40 Accounting Technician l'
41 Building Permit Technician
42 Administrative Assistant ll
42 Police Customer Service Re
42 Video Production Technician
43 Library Specialist
4 3 Senior Storekeeper
44 Account Technician 11
46 Administrative Secretary
47` Library Specialist 11
48 Human Resources Assistant
4 Purchasing Assistant
48 Senior Accounting Technician
4 ` Cemetery Services Assistant
49 Recreation Program Coordinator
49 Senior Administrative Assistant
2 Human Resources Technician
52 Risk Management Technician
?' Workers Compensation Technician
4 Purchasing Supervisor
55> Police Records Supervisor
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
54 Kennel Attendant
y Maintenance Worker
43 echanic Assistant
47` Mechanic 1
51 Mechanic ll
51 Plant Mechanic l
51 Welder
55 Fire Mechanic
55 Plant Mechanic ll
55 senior Welder
59 Senior Mechanic
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
5 Kennel Attendant`
7
0Y Animal Control Officer
55 Animal Control Supervisor
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
3 Police Parking Control Officer
42 CSO/ Public Safety Dispatcher 1
2 Police Customer Seri°ice,.Rep
46 CSO/Public Safety Dispatcher If
50 I.D. Technician
55 Police Records Supervisor
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
-54 Codd Enforcement Officer
58 Senior Code Enforcement Officer'
59 Assistant Planner
63 Associate Planner
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
51 Building Inspector 1
54 Code Enforcement Officer
:55 Building Inspector 11
58 Senior Code Enforcement C7icei
------------------------
34 Fennel Attendant
38Y Cemetery Caretaker I
38Y Grounds Maintenance Worker I
38Y Maintenance Worker
2 Cemetery Caretaker 11
2 Grounds Maintenance Worker 11
3 Tree Trimmer 1
Ota Dark Maintenance Mechanic
6 Senior Grounds MaintenanceWorker 1
47 Senior CemeteryCare-taker
7 "free Trimmer 11
50 Senior Grounds Maintenance: Worker
51 Senior Tree Trimmer
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
52 Senior Building Maintenance Worker
S Building Maintenance Worker
2 Maintenance Custodian
38Y Maintenance Worker
34 fennel Attendant
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Junior Engineer
Y Resident Construction Inspector
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
3 Kennel attendant
38Y Maintenance Worker
47 Line Maintenance Worker
48 Wastewater Treatment Operator 1
49 Laboratory Technician 1
51 Senior Line Maintenance Worker
52 Wastewater Treatment,Operator 11
53 Industrial Waste Inspector
53 Laboratory Technician 11
56 Wastewater Treatment Operator III
58 Wastewater Treatment Operator IV
65 'Regulatory Compliance Officer
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
48Y Traffic Signal Teelmician 11
50 Traffic Signal Technician 1
54 Electrician
60 Senior Communications Electrician Specialist
Water Production Maintenance Supervisor
Water Production Plant Supervisor
34 Kennel Attendant
38Y Maintenance Worker
--------I----------------------------------------------------------------------
42 Water Service Worker
42 Water Meter Reader
46 Senior Water Meter Reader
46 Senior Water Service Worker
46 Water Line/Fire Specialist
47 Line Maintenance Worker
51 Senior Equipment Operator
51 Senior Line Maintenance Worker
5 t Welder
52 Water Quality Technician IT
52 Water Treatment Operator 11
55 Cross Connection Control Inspector
55 Senior Welder
56 Water Treatment Operator III
58 Water Quality Control Officer
58 Water Treatment Operator IV
60 Water Distribution Supervisor
-,----------------------------------------I-------------------------------------
34 Kennel Attendant
38Y Maintenance Worker
47 Asphalt Worker
47 Concrete Worker
•
47 Sign and Paint Worker
51 Senior Asphalt Worker
51 Senior Concrete Worker
51 Senior Equipment Operator
29
51 Senior Sign and Paint Worker
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
3 4 Kennel Attendant
38Y Maintenance Worker
41 Solid Waste Collector
47 Solid Waste Truck Driver
51 Senior Equipment Operator
51 Senior Solid Waste Truck Driver
57 Solid Waste Route Supervisor
Employees being displaced to any position in the Police Department must successfully
complete a background investigation prior to transfer.
30
MOU - RAMME - Cin motion of Councilmember George, seconded by
Cour cilmember Peppier, the City Council unanimously ratified the
Memorandurn of Understanding (MOIJI) with the Redlands Association of Mid-
Management Employees (RAMME) and authorized the Mayor and City Clerk
to execute the MOU on behalf of the City.
MOU - GEAR - On motion of Councilinetriber Geor•ge, seconded by
Councilmember Peppier, the City Council unanimously ratified the
Memorandum of Understanding (1�1101_.t) with the an Bernardino Public
Employees Association representing the ("Tenet-at Employees Association of
Redlands (GEAR) and authorized the Mayor and City 6lerk to execute the
MOU on behalf of the City.
Resolution No. 6218 - Salary - Cyn motion of Coulicifiriernber George, seconded
by COLITICitillember Peppier, the City Council unanimously adopted Resolution
No. 6218, at resolution of the City Council of the City of Redlands establishing a
salary schedule and compensation plan for City employees which reflects the
salary increase,.; for the General Employees Association of Redlands and
Redlands Association of Mid-Mariagement Employees approved by the City
Council in the Memoranda of Understanding for July 1, 2003, through June 30,
2004.
Fluids - Donation -Paramedic Pro-jarn - On motion of Councilmernber George,
seconded by Councilmernber Peppler, the City Council unanimously accepted a
donation of $48,815,80 from the Estate of Jacqueline White to the City of
Redlands Paramedic Program and authorized the expenditure of that amount for
the purchase of paramedic equipment- This generous gesture by Mrs. White was
in appreciation of the medical services provided by the Redlands
Firefigg,liters/Paramedics to her and her late husband.
COMMUNICATI'ONS
o�orts Park aU clate - Public Works Director Mutter introduced Senior Civil
Engineer Bill flernsley xvho presented a PowerPoint reviewing the history and
current status of the Sports Park. Mr. Henisley expressed appreciation to Mayor
Flxws for his work oil this project and apologized that it was not completed
during his term due to circumstances (especially the San Bernardino Kangaroo
Rat) out of their control. Mayor Flaws expressed his appreciation to Public
Works Director Mutter and his staff for their efforts and extended his personal
thanks to Mr. Flernsley for his outstanding performance.
TrailsLUjjdate - An updated trails map was provided to cacti Counciltnember.
Public Works Director Mutter reported the Trails Committee will continue to
work on this project especially in the canyon area and prepared a General Plan
amendment for the entire community. Mayor Flavvs reminded staff and,
Councilillembers that the basic philosophy behind this project is that the trails
do not need development and maintenance, connectivity is very important, and
November 18, 2003
Page 6