Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutContracts & Agreements_169-2005three tenants m a commercial center, was unanimously adopted on motion of Councilmember Gilbreath, seconded by Councilmember Gil Pre -Annexation Agreement No. 05-03 - Mark Buoye - On motion of Councilmember Gilbreath, seconded by Councilmember Gil, the City Council unanimously approved Pre -Annexation Agreement No 05-03 for a 2 82 acre parcel located on the east side of Wabash Avenue, approximately 420 feet north of Panorama Drive m the Crafton Area and authorized the Mayor to execute, and the City Clerk to attest to, the document on behalf of the City Funding Agreement - Standard Pacific Homes - On motion of Councilmember Gilbreath, seconded by Councilmember Gil, the City Council unanimously approved an environmental consultmg funding agreement with Standard Pacific Homes for an application for the development of a single family planned residential development which requires the preparation of an Initial Study Environmental Checklist and may require an Environmental Impact Report and authorized the Mayor to execute, and the City Clerk to attest to, the document on behalf of the City Agreement - Standard Pacific Homes - On motion of Councilmember Gilbreath, seconded by Councilmember Gil, the City Council unanimously approved a contract with ECORP Consulting, Inc. for preparation of an Environmental Impact Report for Agricultural Preserve Removal No. 107, Williamson Act Contract Removal Nos. 8 and 9, Zone Change No. 409, Conditional Use Permit No. 840, Tentative Tract No 16689, and Demolition No 111. Subdivision Improvement Agreement - Pence Construction, Apphcant - On motion of Councilmember Gilbreath, seconded by Councilmember Gil, the City Council unanimously approved a subdivision improvement agreement for Parcel Map No 16164 for Minor Subdivision No 266 to subdivide an approximately 1 66 acre site into three commercial lots located on the north side of Plum Lane and west of Alabama Street and east of Idaho Street and authorized the Mayor to execute, and the City Clerk to attest to, the document on behalf of the City Trails - Flood Control Right -of -Way - Councilmember Peppier expressed concerns about the future financial liability of the City if we proceeded with the request to enter into a common use agreement addressing responsibility for maintenance, operations and habihty for trails constructed in flood control right- of-way Community Development Director Shaw explained the City currently has two development projects that have been approved subject to a condition that they construct a trail adjacent to their property Before they can proceed for issuance of a building permit, a Memorandum of Understanding with the San Bernardino County Flood Control District must be approved by both the City and the County Subsequent to this Memorandum of Understanding, it will be September 6, 2005 Page 2 AGREEMENT TO PROVIDE PROFESSIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL CONSULTING SERVICES FOR THE PREPARATION OF AN ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT REPORT AND ASSOCIATED ENVIRONMENTAL DOCUMENTS This Agreement is made and entered into this 6th day of September, 2005, by and between the City of Redlands, a municipal corporation ("City") and ECORP Consulting, Inc ("Consultant"), who are sometimes individually referred to herein as a "Party," and collectively, as the "Parties " In consideration of the mutual promises contained herein, City and Consultant agree as follows 11 ARTICLE 1 - ENGAGEMENT OF CONSULTANT City hereby engages Consultant to prepare an Environmental Impact Report (EIR) and associated environmental documents (the "Services") for the Standard Pacific Homes Project described as Tentative Tract No 16689, Cup No 840, Zone Change No 409, Agricultural Preserve Removal No 107, Williamson Act Removal No 8 and Demolition No 111 (the "Project") 1 2 All work performed by Consultant under this Agreement shall be done in a professional manner, and Consultant represents that it has the skill and professional expertise necessary to provide high quality Services to City at the level of competency presently maintained by other practicing professional consultants in the industry providing similar types of services ARTICLE 2 - RESPONSIBILITIES OF CONSULTANT 2 1 The Services which Consultant shall perform are more particularly described in Exhibit "A," entitled "Proposal to Prepare an Environmental Impact Report for Standard Pacific Homes Residential Development," which is attached hereto and incorporated herein by this reference 2 2 Consultant shall comply with all applicable Federal, State and local rules, laws and regulations in the performance of this Agreement including but not limited to all applicable Labor Code and prevailing wage laws, and all non-discrimination laws including the Americans with Disabilities Act ARTICLE 3 - RESPONSIBILITIES OF CITY 3 1 City shall place at disposal of Consultant all available information in its possession pertinent to the Project 3 2 City will provide access to and make all provisions for Consultant to enter upon City -owned property or right-of-way as required by Consultant to perform the Services pursuant to this j:cc reportslplanningleir contract std pacific.wpd 1 Agreement 3 3 City has designated its Community Development Director, Jeff Shaw, to act as City's representative with respect to the Services to be performed under this Agreement, and such person shall have complete authority to transmit instructions, receive information, interpret and define City's policies and decisions with respect to the Services ARTICLE 4 - PERIOD OF SERVICE 4 1 Consultant shall perform the Services in a prompt and diligent manner in accordance with the Schedule incorporated within Exhibit "A " ARTICLE 5 - PAYMENT AND NOTICE 5 1 The total compensation for Consultant's performance of the Services shall not exceed $56,490 City shall pay Consultant on a time and materials basis at the hourly rates as shown within the Rate Schedule for Professional Services attached as Exhibit "A " 5 2 Payments by City to Consultant shall be made within thirty (30) days after receipt and approval of Consultant's invoice, by warrant payable to Consultant Invoices shall be billed on a monthly basis 5 3 All notices, shall be provided in writing and may be given by personal delivery or by mail Notices sent by mail should be addressed as follows City Asher Hartel, Senior Planner City of Redlands Community Development Department PO Box 3005 Redlands, CA 92373 Consultant Anne Surdzial, Project Manager ECORP Consulting, Inc 412 East State Street Redlands, CA 92373 When so addressed, such notices shall be deemed given upon deposit in the United States mail, in all other instances, notices, shall be deemed given at the time of actual delivery Changes may be made in the names and addresses of the person to whom notices, are to be given by giving notice pursuant to this paragraph j:cc rcportslpianninglor contract std pacific wild 2 ARTICLE 6 - INSURANCE AND INDEMNIFICATION 6 1 Consultant's Insurance to be Primary All insurance required by this Agreement shall be maintained by Consultant throughout its performance of the Services and shall be primary with respect to City and non-contributing to any insurance or self-insurance maintained by City Consultant shall provide City with Certificates of Insurance and endorsements evidencing such insurance prior to commencement of the Services 6 2 Workers' Compensation and Employer's Liability A Consultant shall secure and maintain Workers' Compensation and Employer's Liability insurance throughout its performance of the Services in amounts which meet the statutory requirement with an insurance carrier acceptable to City Such insurance shall be primary and non-contributing to any insurance or self-insurance maintained by City The insurance policy shall include a provision prohibiting modification or cancellation of the policy except upon thirty (30) days prior written notice to City Certificates of Insurance shall be delivered to City prior to commencement of the Services B Consultant expressly waives all rights to subrogation against City, its elected officials, officers and employees for losses arising from work performed by Consultant for City by expressly waiving Consultant's immunity for injuries to Consultant's employees and agrees that the obligation to indemnify, defend and hold harmless provided for in this Agreement extends to any claim brought by or in behalf of any employee of Consultant This waives is mutually negotiated by the Parties This subsection shall not apply to any damage resulting from the sole negligence of City, its agents and employees To the extent any of the damages referenced herein were caused by or resulted from the concurrent negligence of City, its agents or employees, the obligations provided herein to indemnify, defend and hold harmless are valid and enforceable only to the extent of the negligence of Consultant, its officers, agents and employees 6 3 Hold Harmless and Indemnification. Consultant shall indemnify, hold harmless and defend City and its elected officials, agents, and employees from and against any and all claims, losses or liability, including attorneys' fees, arising from injury or death to persons or damage to property occasioned by any act, omission or failure of Consultant, its officers, agents and employees in performing the Services required by this Agreement City shall defend, indemnify and hold harmless Consultant from and against any and all claims, losses, expenses, damages, demands, judgments, causes of action, sults, and liability in tort, contract, or any other basis and of every other kind and character whatsoever, to the extent that claims are caused by, result from or arise out of City's sole negligence, gross negligence, intentional misconduct or strict liability i:cc reportslplannmgleir contract std pacific wpd 6 4 Assignment Consultant is expressly prohibited from assigning any of the Services described in this Agreement without the prior written consent of City In the event of mutual agreement between the Parties to assign a portion of the Services, Consultant shall add the assignee as an additional insured and provide City with the insurance endorsements prior to any Services being performed by the assignee Assignment does not include printing or other customary reimbursable expenses that may be provided for in this Agreement 6 5 Comprehensive General Liability Insurance Consultant shall secure and maintain in force throughout its performance of the Services comprehensive general liability insurance with carriers acceptable to City Minimum coverage of one million dollars ($1,000,000) per occurrence and two million dollars ($2,000,000) aggregate for public liability, property damage and personal injury is required City shall be named as an additional insured and the insurance policy shall include a provision prohibiting modification or cancellation of the policy except upon thirty (30) days prior written notice to City Such insurance shall be primary and non-contributing to any insurance or self-insurance maintained by City Certificates of insurance and endorsements shall be delivered to City prior to commencement of the Services 6 6 Professional Liability Insurance Consultant shall secure and maintain professional liability insurance throughout it performance of the Services in the amount of one million dollars ($1,000,000) per claim made Consultant shall maintain professional liability insurance throughout the duration of the Project Certificate of liability insurance and endorsement shall be delivered to City prior to commencement of the Services 6 7 Business Auto Liability Insurance. Consultant shall have business auto liability coverage, with minimum limits of one million ($1,000,000) per occurrence, combined single limit for bodily injury liability and property damage liability This coverage shall include all Consultant owned vehicles used on the project, hired and non -owned vehicles, and employee non -ownership vehicles City shall be named as an additional insured and a certificate of insurance shall be delivered to City prior to commencement of the Services ARTICLE 7 - GENERAL CONSIDERATIONS 7 1 In the event any action is commenced to enforce or interpret any of the terms or conditions of this Agreement the prevailing Party shall, in addition to any costs and other relief, be entitled to recover its reasonable attorneys' fees, including fees for in-house counsel of the Parties at rates prevailing in San Bernardino County, California 7 2 The Consultant's key personnel proposed for the Project is as follows Anne Surdzial, AICP, Project Manager Evelyn Chandler, Cultural Resources Manager Donald Mitchell, Principal Biologist and Inland Empire Operations Manager J:cc reportslplannsnglcsr contract std pacific wpd 4 Ms Surdzial will be supported by the following subconsultants Stephen J Montgomery, SJM Biological Consultants Valorie Thompson, Scientific Resources Associated Consultant agrees that these key personnel will be made available and assigned to City's Project, and that they will not be replaced without concurrence from City 7 3 All documents, records, drawings, electronic data files and data base, photographic prints and negatives, designs and specifications, cost estimates, and other documents developed by Consultant pursuant to this Agreement, and any copyright interest in the above-described documents, shall become the property of City and shall be delivered to City upon completion of the Services 7 4 Consultant and City agree that Consultant is, for all purposes under this Agreement, an independent contractor with respect to the Services provided pursuant to this Agreement and not an employee of City All qualified personnel provided by Consultant pursuant to the provisions of this Agreement are to be employed by Consultant for its account only, and in no event shall Consultant or any personnel retained by it be deemed to have been employed by City or engaged by City for the account of or on behalf of City Nothing in this Agreement shall be considered to create the relationship of employer and employee between the Parties 7 5 Unless earlier terminated as stipulated below, this Agreement shall terminate upon completion and acceptance of the Services by City 7 6 Upon receipt of a termination notice, Consultant shall (1) promptly discontinue all Services and (2) deliver or otherwise make available to City, copies of any data, design calculations, drawings, specifications, reports, estimates, summaries, and such other information and materials as may have been accumulated by Consultant in performing the Services required by this Agreement Consultant shall be compensated on a pro -rata basis for any work completed up until notice of termination 7 7 This Agreement, including the attachments incorporated herein by reference, represents the entire agreement and understanding between the Parties as to the matters contained herein and any prior negotiations, proposals or oral agreements are superseded by this Agreement Any amendment to this Agreement shall be in writing and approved by the City Council of City and signed by City and Consultant 7 8 This Agreement shall be governed by and construed in accordance with the laws of the State of California J:ce reportslplanntnglew contract std pacific wpd 5 IN WITNESS WHEREOF, duly authorized representatives of the Parties have signed in confirmation of this Agreement CITY OF REDLANDS By ECORP Consulting, Inc ( City CJ By 4%i� [. Date / sEF 1 ZOoS- Donald R Mitchell, Inland Empire Operations Manager ):cc reports\plannmgleir contract std pacific.wpd 6 Proposal to Prepare and Environmental Impact Report for Standard Pacific Homes Residential Development (Tentative Tract Map No. 16689, CUP No. 840, Zone Change No. 409, Agricultural Preserve Removal No. 107, Williamson Act Removal No. 8, and Demolition No. 111) Prepared by ECORP Consulting, Inc. ENVIRONMENTAL CONSULTANTS 412 East State Street Redlands, California 92373 Prepared for City of Redlands Community Development Department 35 Cajon Street, Suite 20 Redlands, California 92373 Donald R Mitchell Inland Empire Operations Manager 1.0 Project Understanding and Approach 1.1 Project Understanding ECORP Consulting, Inc appreciates the opportunity to respond to the Request for Proposal (RFP) for the Standard Pacific Homes Residential Development. We understand that the project applicant, Standard Pacific Homes, has submitted a number of technical studies, prepared by reputable consultants, to facilitate environmental analysis according to the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA). Prior to preparing this proposal, ECORP staff reviewed the project information made available to potential bidders by the City An ECORP staff biologist and CEQA specialist also made a pre-bid visit to the site, in order to better identify and clarify issues for the proposal The documents reviewed included • a Traffic Impact Study by Urban Crossroads, • a Preliminary Noise Study by Urban Crossroads, e a Geotechnical Investigation by Geocon; • an Environmental Site Assessment by Carlin Environmental Consulting, • a Cultural Resources Assessment by Archaeological Associates; e a Hydrology Summary Report by Hicks and Hartwick, o a General Biological Assessment by TeraCor; a a San Bernardino Kangaroo Rat Presence/Absence Trapping Study by ENVIRA, and a an Independent Review Letter Report by Tom Dodson & Associates Based on the analysis of the project in the technical reports, the City has determined that the project has the potential to significantly affect the Federally -listed (Endangered) San Bernardino Merriam's kangaroo rat (SBKR) (Dipodomys mernami parvus) ECORP Consulting, Inc. ENVIRONMENTAL CONSULTANTS 1 2 Approach to CEQA Compliance It is our understanding that the City has requested that the CEQA contractor prepare the Initial Study for the proposed project to determine the appropriate CEQA document for the project (either a Mitigated Negative Declaration [MND] or an Environmental Impact Report [EIR]) There are advantages and disadvantages to each document The MND requires less public review time; however it offers less legal protection for the City and requires the applicant to mitigate all impacts The EIR requires more public review time, but offers greater legal protection and does not require mitigation of all impacts It is probable that the City will not be able to make a decision on which document to pursue without the information and analysis that will be provided in the Initial Study ECORP Consulting's approach to the preparation of the EIR is to use the existing documentation prepared for the project as the primary source of information We have identified a few areas where additional or supplemental technical studies may be required, described below. We have provided the scope and cost for these studies as optional tasks (see Sections 3.2.1 and 3 2 2) Biological Resources. Multiple biological resources studies have been performed on the proposed project site The primary biological resources issue for the development of the site is the presence of the Federally -listed (Endangered) SBKR (Dipodomys merrrami parvus). In October 2003, protocol -level trapping surveys were on the site conducted by a permitted biologist and failed to detect SBKR on the project site Subsequently, an unauthorized trapping effort (i.e., a consultant inadvertently trapped on the Standard Pacific TT 16689 site) did identify SBKR on the northern portion of the project site An attempt was made to exclude SBKR from the southern portion of the site by installing a fence However, it's not clear whether SBKR may already have existed in the more southerly portions of the site at that time. The City subsequently hired a consultant to perform a peer review related to the SBKR issues for the site This consultant concluded that the biologist who monitored the fencing may not have been appropriately qualified (i.e., permitted by USFWS) and that there is still no conclusive evidence that SBKR may not exist in multiple areas of the site (Dodson 2005). Therefore they recommended a protocol -level trapping study of the entire site We are proposing an additional SBKR habitat assessment by Mr Stephen Montgomery (S.JM Biological Consultants). Based upon the previous SBKR documentation for the site, we may recommend protocol -level trapping throughout the site This trapping effort is included as an optional task (see Section 3 2 1) ECORP Consulting, Inc. ENVIRONMENTAL CONSULTANTS Eligibility Evaluations for On -Site Structures The cultural resources assessment prepared by Archaeological Associates mentioned the agricultural -related structures on the site only in passing, describing them as"modern" No information was given on how this determination was made We have proposed a reconnaissance -level survey by an archaeologist that specializes in architectural history/historic archaeology as part of the Initial Study process This reconnaissance -level visit is included in our proposal If it is determined that the structures may not be warranted, ECORP will conduct an evaluation to determine if the structures are eligible for listing The evaluation is included as an optional task (see Section 3.2 2) ECORP Consulting, Inc. ENVIRONMENTAL CONSULTANTS 3 2.0 Corporate Description, Key Personnel, and Description of Experience 2.1 Project Team This project would be managed and staffed from ECORP Consulting's Inland Empire office in Redlands ECORP has assisted public and pnvate land owners with environmental regulation compliance since 1987. We offer full service capability, from initial baseline environmental studies through environmental planning review, permitting negotiation, liaison to obtain legal agreements, mitigation design, construction supervision, and monitoring and compliance reporting. We bring together an experienced team of CEQA/NEPA specialists, engineers, hydrologists, biologists, wetland specialists, environmental analysts, archaeologists, and geographic information system specialists ECORP is a certified small business in the State of California and under many federal NAICS and SIC codes ECORP has a total of 95 employees, including 17 employees assigned to the Redlands office We conduct environmental analysis for federal, state, regional, and local government and private clients ECORP has established professional working relationships with federal and state regulatory agencies, based on technical excellence and a thorough understanding of regulatory processes. We are experienced with the California Fish and Game Code, Section 1600; the regulatory requirements of the federal Clean Water Act (CWA), Sections 401, 402, and 404; the National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA), the National Historic Preservation Act (NHPA), Sections 106 and 110, the federal Endangered Species Act (ESA), Sections 7 and 10, the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA), the California Endangered Species Act (CESA), and the Coastal Zone Management Act (CZMA) A partial list of our environmental services includes. ECORP Consulting, Inc. FNV1RONMENTAL CONSULTANTS • NEPA/CEQA Review, Compliance and Documentation o Special -Status Species Inventory and Regulatory Compliance • Habitat Restoration Planning, Design and Construction • Fisheries, Amphibian, and Aquatic Habitat Assessment • Stream Restoration and Surveys • Wetland Assessment and Regulatory Compliance • Benthic Macroinvertebrate Bioassessment Studies e Cultural Resource Management • Archaeological Test and Data Recovery Programs • Cultural Resource Surveys and Management Plans • Native American Consultations o Cultural Resources and Natural Resources Construction Monitoring o Historic Structure Analysis o Paleontological Mitigation Plans and Monitoring Services e Water Resources Operations and Water Quality Management • Fluvial Geomorphology and Hydrology o Open Space Management • Environmental Permitting and Compliance e Storm Water Pollution Prevention Planning (SWPPP) • Geographic Information System (GIS) and Computer -Aided Design (CAD) • Mitigation Planning and Monitoring e Arboriculture and Urban/Community Forestry • Forestry and Fire Management Also included on our project team is S)M Biological Consultants, who will provide additional expertise in SBKR issues, and Scientific Resources Associated, who will provide additional expertise in air quality analysis The qualifications for these small, specialty subcontractors are provided in Section 2 2. 2.2 Key Personnel The EIR preparation will be managed by Ms. Anne Surdzial, AICP. Ms. Surdzial is ECORP's CEQA/NEPA Manager. She has 15 years experience preparing and managing the preparation of ISs/EAs and EIRs/EISs for a variety of projects subject to review under the CEQA and NEPA. She is also experienced in land use planning issues and is a former planner for the City of Redlands. She is currently the Project Manager for the EIR for the Bulldog Commons project for the City While employed at another firm, Ms Surdzial was the Project Manager for the CEQA Initial Study and NEPA Environmental Assessment for the flood control improvements on the Mission Zanja between 9th Street and 7th Street In October 2004, Ms Surdzial was a speaker/panel member ECORP Consulting, Inc. ENVIRONMENTAL CONSULTANTS for the California Association of Environmental Professionals' CEQA Basics Workshop She has a B.S. in Environmental Science from U C. Riverside Don Mitchell has 18 years of experience in the field of environmental science, with particular emphasis on wildlife assessments, impact analysis, and project management He has extensive experience in conducting biological studies, and focused threatened and endangered species surveys, sensitive habitat surveys He has also conducted or managed surveys for the San Bernardino kangaroo rat, Stephens' kangaroo rat, California gnatcatcher, desert tortoise, Mohave ground squirrel, and a wide variety of southern California and Mojave Desert terrestrial plant and wildlife species Ms. Evelyn Chandler will provide expertise for cultural resources. Ms. Chandler is a graduate of the University of Redlands, with 15 years of experience in cultural resources management Ms Chandler has managed several projects involving the evaluation of structures in Redlands, including the 65 -acre Griffin Industries residential development in southeast Redlands, the Bulldog Commons project at Grove and Sylvan and the First Protestant Reformed Church at the site of the new Boys and Girls Club She also evaluated impacts to the Zanja as part of the flood control improvements at 9th Street for the IS/EA. Steve Montgomery founded SJM Biological Consultants in 1983, and has over 20 years of experience managing and conducting field surveys, analyzing data, and preparing reports for diverse types of biological studies Mr Montgomery specializes in small mammal species, and he holds a U S Fish and Wildlife Service (USFWS) permit to trap and handle SBKR, a California Department of Fish and Game (CDFG) Memorandum of Understanding (MOU) to trap and handle SBKR His other qualifications include USFWS permits and CDFG MOUS for the Stephens' kangaroo rat and Pacific pocket mouse, and USFWS permits for Yuma clapper rail, California gnatcatcher, and Amargosa vole Mr. Montgomery conducted SBKR habitat assessment and trapping studies for the Sector 8 and Fairmont projects in Redlands He was also the SBKR expert for the Metropolitan Water District's Inland Feeder Project and the U S Army Corps of Engineer's Seven Oaks Dam project He has also conducted trapping and habitat assessment surveys for SBKR at various locations in the Santa Ana River, Lytle Creek, and Cajon Creek washes for sand and gravel mining companies Valorie Thompson, Ph.D., Principal of Scientific Resources Associated, has over 15 years of experience in environmental planning, air quality studies, air toxics emission evaluations, health ECORP Consulting, Inc. ENV1RONAIENTAL CONSULTANTS 6 risk assessments, process safety management, hazard and operability studies, off-site consequence analysis, and atmospheric dispersion modeling. She has managed numerous environmental planning, air quality, and risk assessment projects. Dr Thompson has also assisted government clients in the development of air emission inventories and compliance strategies for large military bases She has a Ph.D. in Chemical Engineering from Purdue University A copy of resumes for all key personnel are attached to this proposal. 2.3 Project Experience The following projects describe the CEQA project experience of ECORP Consulting and the key personnel assigned to this project. EIR for Bulldog Commons Development Project Client City of Redlands Project End Date. January 2006 (est) Key Personnel. Anne Surdzial (Project Manager), Don Mitchell, Evelyn Chandler, Valorie Thompson ECORP Consulting is currently preparing an EIR for the development of a 3 -acre site into an apartment complex. The Bulldog Commons development consists of 40 dwelling units in two, 2 - story buildings in an infill area in the City of Redlands near the University of Redlands. As part of intersection improvements required to provide access to the project site, the Mill Creek Zanja channel would be affected. This portion of the channel is listed on the National Register of Historic Places (NRNP) and the California Register of Historical Resources (CRHR), because it is the earliest remaining civil engineering project in southern California In addition to impacts to Cultural Resources related to the Zanja, hydrology and biological resources impacts were also key environmental issues. ECORP Consulting, Inc. ENVLRONMENTAL CONSULTANTS 7 Program EIR for the Crafton Hills College Master Plan Client Pilot Engineering/San Bernardino Community College District Project End Date June 2006 (est) Key Personnel Anne Surdzial (Project Manager), Evelyn Chandler, Don Mitchell, Valorie Thompson ECORP Consulting is currently preparing an EIR for the Master Plan for Crafton Hills College, a community college located in Yucaipa, California The Master Plan provided for the expansion of the college infrastructure and facilities through 2025. Constraints analyses were also prepared for biological resources, archaeological resources, and paleontologic resources EIR for the Expansion of the Barstow Sanitary Landfill Client County of San Bernardino Project End Date • January 2006 (est) Key Personnel Anne Surdzial (Project Manager), Evelyn Chandler The County of San Bernardino planned to consolidate its landfill services into regional landfills supported by transfer stations to save landfill operating costs The Barstow Sanitary Landfill was selected as a regional landfill To serve the regional population previously served by multiple, smaller landfills, and to serve future populations, the County proposed to expand the Barstow Sanitary Landfill both vertically and horizontally An Initial Study, Environmental Impact Report, Mitigation Monitoring and Reporting Program and supporting technical studies were prepared for the landfill expansion Issues of concern included biological resources (desert tortoise, Mohave ground squirrel, sensitive plants), aesthetics, traffic, noise, air quality, cultural resources, hazards and hazardous materials, and water quality. On -Call Master Services Agreement for Environmental Services Client Yucaipa Valley Water District Project End Date Ongoing Key Personnel. Anne Surdzial (Program Manager), Don Mitchell, Evelyn Chandler, Valorie Thompson, Steve Montgomery Program Manager for on-call environmental services for water and wastewater projects in the cities of Yucaipa and Calimesa with the Yucaipa Valley Water District. Under this contract, responsible for determining the appropriate environmental documentation and studies to comply ECORP Consulting, Inc. ENVIRONMENTAL CONSULTANTS 8 with CEQA and to obtain the appropriate environmental permits for YVWD projects Task orders completed under this on-call contract include the preparation and filing of categorical exemptions for small projects, the preparation of IS/MNDs for potable and non -potable pipelines and reservoirs, and construction monitoring. Third -Party Review of Martin Ranch EIR Client. City of San Bernardino Development Services Department Project End Date December 2005 (est) Key Personnel Anne Surdzial (Project Manager) ECORP Consulting is currently providing third -party peer review services for an EIR and technical studies for the Martin Ranch project, a large, hillside residential subdivision. ECORP is providing review services for the EIR, ail notices, Mitigation Monitoring and Reporting Program, Findings, Statement of Overriding Considerations, and Traffic Impact Analysis Report. IS and EA for Flood Control Improvements on Mission Zanja Creek Client City of Redlands Project End Date October 2002 Key Personnel Anne Surdzial (Project Manager), Evelyn Chandler ECORP staff, while employed elsewhere, prepared an IS and EA for improvements to an approximately 500 -foot segment of the Mission Zanja Creek, between 9th Street and 7th Street in the City of Redlands. ECORP Consulting, Inc. ENVIRONMENTAL CONSULTANTS 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 2.4 Other Information ECORP Consulting has not conducted any work for Standard Pacific Homes or Hicks and Hartwick in the last 5 years We have no pending or settled legal challenges Involving environmental documents prepared by our firm ECORP Consulting has performed the following work for Urban Environs in the last 5 years Description of Project Project Location Date Complete Reconnaissance Level Biological Resources Survey on 55 acre Riley's Farm site Oak Glen April 2005 Focused Plant Surveys, Coastal California Gnatcatcher Surveys, SBKR and Stephens' Kangaroo Rat Habitat Assessment, and a Wetlands Delineation on 60 acre Sector 8 site Redlands May 2005 Focused Plant Surveys, Coastal California Gnatcatcher Surveys, Small Mammal Trapping, and a Wetlands Delineation on 40 -acre Fairmont site Redlands August 2005 (est) ECORP Consulting, Inc. ENVIRONMENTAL CONSULTANTS 10 3.0 Scope of Work The project will be evaluated at the completion of Task 2 to determine if an MND or an EIR is the appropnate environmental document As requested in the RFP, this scope of work assumes that the Initial Study will recommend the preparation of an EIR. 3 1 Task 1— Project Kickoff, Preparation of a Project Description Within 5 working days of the Notice to Proceed, ECORP will attend a project kickoff meeting with the City planning staff, project applicant, and any others requested by the City (such as public works staff). We have assumed we will receive copies of previously -prepared technical reports for the project at this meeting ECORP will prepare a project description based on information provided by the project applicant. The project description will describe the project's location, characteristics, and construction scenario ECORP will provide three copies of the project description to the City for review and comment The revised version of the project description will be contained in the Initial Study Alternatives to the project will be developed in Task 3, if an EIR is determined to be the appropriate CEQA document 3.2 Task 2 — Initial Study A CEQA Initial Study is generally used to determine which CEQA document is appropriate for a project (Negative Declaration [ND], Mitigated Negative Declaration [MND], or EIR) However, an Initial Study may also be useful even if the Lead Agency has already concluded that an EIR is required CEQA Guidelines Section 15063 (a)(1) states, If the lead agency can determine that an EIR will clearly be required for the project, an initial study is not required but may still be desirable. The Initial Study can be used to eliminate resources from discussion in the EIR that are clearly not affected by the proposed project. ECORP will prepare an Initial Study for the proposed project, and provide written justification of answers. ECORP Consulting, Inc. ENVIRONMENTAL CONSULTANTS 11 To determine the scope of the project impacts, and if the impacts can be mitigated, additional study for air quality, biological resources, and cultural resources may be required at the Initial Study stage The scopes of work for these resources are provided below, and their costs are provided in the cost estimate for the Initial Study We have also provided optional tasks for additional technical studies for biological resources and cultural resources, which are discussed in Sections 2 2 1 and 2 2 2 The costs for these resources are presented separately from our main cost estimate. Air Quality. Included in ECORP's cost estimate for Task 2 is an analysis of the air quality impacts of the construction and operation of the proposed project According to the SCAQMD webpage, the screening tables in Chapter 6 of the CEQA Air Quality Handbook should no longer be used under any circumstances because they are based on obsolete mobile source emission factors and trip generation data. Methodologies in the Appendix to Chapter 9 of the CEQA Air Quality Handbook or use a land use model should be used until new screening tables are developed Emissions associated with the construction phase of the project will be estimated The emissions estimates will be based on information provided by the project design team with regard to construction requirements, and/or will be developed based on standardized approaches as presented in the South Coast Air Quality Management District's CEQA Air Quality Handbook for construction of single-family residential developments. The significance of the emissions based on appropriate significance criteria developed by the City of Redlands and the South Coast Air Quality Management District's CEQA significance thresholds. Where required, SRA will evaluate mitigation measures to reduce potential impacts associated with construction. This assessment will address criteria pollutant impacts Operational impacts associated with the project mainly include increases in traffic and area sources such as energy use. Based on the traffic analysis provided by the applicant, SRA will evaluate the potential for a significant air quality impacts associated with traffic. In the event that the traffic analysis projects a degradation in LOS at any affected intersection to LOS E or worse, SRA will conducted a detailed CO "hot spots" analysis to determine the potential for an exceedance of the CO standard The analysis will be conducted in accordance with Caltrans guidelines. For the purpose of providing a cost estimate, SRA assumes that one intersection will be evaluated for CO "hot spots." Biological Resources Our scope of work for the Initial Study includes a habitat assessment for SBKR on the entire property by Steve Montgomery, who holds a USFWS permit to trap and handle SBKR and a CDFG MOU to trap and handle SBKR Based on this habitat assessment, he 12 ECORP Consulting, Inc. ENVIRONMENTAL CONSULTANTS will recommend if additional SBKR trapping studies will be required to confirm the presence/absence of the species on the site, particularly on the southern portion of the property. The scope of work for this trapping study is in Section 3 2 1, as an optional task If the City agrees with this approach, this optional task will be conducted and the results will be presented in the Initial Study Cultural Resources, A reconnaissance -level survey of the agricultural buildings/structures on the site will be conducted as part of the scope of work for the Initial Study The structures within the project area will be examined by a Historic Archaeologist to assess their approximate date of construction based on architectural characteristics and construction materials and techniques If there is a possibility that the buildings were constructed prior to 1955, then ECORP will conduct the optional task described in Section 3 2.2. This task will better determine the age of the buildings and if they are eligible for listing Also included in the cost for the Initial Study are records searches for paleontological resources with the San Bernardino County museum and Native American resources with the Native American Heritage commission These records searches were not provided with the applicant - submitted reports We have assumed, for costing purposes, that the City or applicant can provide ECORP with a copy of the archaeological resources records search conducted by the applicant's consultant 3.2.1 Optional Task - San Bernardino Kangaroo Rat Studies Based upon review of the previous biological studies, the proposed assessment by Mr Stephen Montgomery, and upon authorization by the City of the optional task, a USFWS protocol -level trapping study for SBKR will be conducted by a USFWS permitted biologist. Following completion of the study, a report detailing the methods and results of the surveys will be submitted to the City and the USFWS. The results of the trapping study will be incorporated into the Biological Resources section of the Initial Study. 3.2.2 Optional Task - Eligibility Evaluations for On -Site Structures If the structures appear to be of historic age (i.e , over 50 years old), based on the reconnaissance -level survey included as part of the Initial Study, additional research will be conducted to determine the exact dates of construction and to evaluate them for significance to the California Register of Historical Resources (CRHR) Evaluation methods will include archival 13 ECORP Consulting, Inc. ENVIRONMENTAL CONSULTANTS research to determine if the structures are associated with any significant events or persons in local history and detailed field recordation of the structures An evaluation report will be prepared documenting the methods and results of the study The report will provide recommendations on the CRHR eligibility of the structures, and if considered they are considered eligible, will assess impacts to the structures from the proposed development of the parcel, and recommend mitigation measures as applicable 3.3 Task 3 — Notice of Preparation/Administrative Draft EIR 3.3.1 Notice of Preparation ECORP will prepare the Notice of Preparation, soliciting participation in determining the scope of the EIR. The Initial Study will be attached to the NOP ECORP will distribute 50 copies of the approved IS/NOP package for distribution to the County Clerk, various public agencies whose approval and/or comments are required (Responsible Agencies), agencies with resources affected by the project (Trustee Agencies), and interested parties and groups Within the 30 -day public review and comment period, Responsible Agencies, Trustee Agencies, and members of the public may provide comments about the EIR contents and the project in general 3.3.3 Administrative Draft EIR An Administrative Draft EIR will be submitted to the City for review and comment prior to the preparation of the Draft EIR. The EIR will be prepared using technical and environmental reports provided by the Applicant, the air quality analysis, and the results any optional tasks chosen by the City The EIR will include the topics for which impacts were identified either as "potentially significant" or "less than significant with mitigation incorporated" in the Initial Study checklist. It is important to carry forward the mitigation required in the Initial Study to the EIR, so that it will be documented in the Mitigation Monitoring and Reporting Program (MMRP). However, it is our approach that the majority of the documentation in the EIR will be for those issues where more information or analysis was required, and a determination of significance could not be made in the Initial Study The EIR will also analyze up to three alternatives' an alternative of less intensive development, an alternative with more intensive development, and the No Project Alternative We have assumed that the applicant would provide any engineering data required for the alternatives development. ECORP Consulting, Inc. ENVIRONMENTAL CONSULTANTS 14 A total of three copies of the Administrative Draft EIR will be provided to the City for review and comment. For costing purposes, we have assumed that the technical reports prepared by the Applicant will be incorporated by reference and will not be included in the EIR as technical appendices 3.4 Task 4 — Draft EIR and Notices After review and comment on the Draft EIR, ECORP will revise the EIR and print sufficient copies for public review. We will also prepare the Notice of Completion and Notice of Availability to accompany the Draft EIR and for publication in a newspaper of general circulation We have made the following assumptions regarding document and notice circulation' • ECORP Consulting will print and distribute 29 hard copies and one electronic copy of the EIR as follows - Fifteen copies will be sent to the State Clearinghouse - Three hard copies and one electronic copy of the Draft EIR will be provided to the City - One hard copy will be provided to the AK Smiley Public Library - ECORP and the City will develop a list of interested agencies and other interested parties These agencies/individuals will be mailed a complete copy of the EIR It is assumed that the list will contain no more than 10 addresses. • The City will provide a list of surrounding property owners. These owners will receive a Notice of Availability, stating that the EIR is available for review at the Planning Department and at the library • ECORP will post the Notice of Availability with the County Clerk We have assumed that the City will arrange to have the notice published in the newspaper, and will pay all fees associated with newspaper publication and with County Clerk filing 3.5 Task 5 - Administrative Final EIR/Draft MMRP ECORP will prepare an Administrative Final EIR, consisting of copies of comment letters received on the Draft EIR, responses to these comments, any errata sheets required based on the comments, and the Draft MMRP Three copies of the Draft EIR will be prepared for City review ECORP Consulting, Inc. ENVIRONMENTAL CONSULTANTS 15 3.6 Task 6 - Final EIR/Final MMRP/Notice of Determination After City comments on the Administrative Final EIR, ECORP will prepare the Final EIR and the Notice of Determination. We will file the Notice of Determination with the County Clerk, and mail the Final EIR to the required agencies and individuals We have assumed printing of 20 Final EIRs, including 3 copies for the City We will also prepare one electronic copy for the City. We have assumed that the City will pay all filing fees associated with the County Clerk 3.7 Task 7 - Meetings In addition to the kickoff meeting included in Task 1, the ECORP Project Manager will attend an estimated five meetings two for the Environmental Review Committee and three for both the Planning Commission and City Council We have also proposed a meeting at the conclusion of Task 2 to review the recommendation of an EIR or MND. ECORP Consulting, Inc. ENVIRONMENTAL CONSULTANTS 16 4.0 Preliminary Schedule ECORP has prepared a preliminary project schedule based on the most lengthy time frame for the CEQA documentation This schedule ends in approximately 9 months from the finalization of the contract. We have assumed that the optional tasks will be chosen, and that an EIR will be recommended as the most appropriate environmental document If the optional tasks are not required and/or an MND is recommended, the time frame to complete the project would be shorter A project schedule with the optional tasks and with an MND is estimated to end in February or March 2006. Milestone/Deliverable Time Frame Completion Date Selection of Consultant lst City Council Meeting in September September 6, 2005 Contract Finalized 1 week from City Council meeting September 16, 2005 Task 1• Kickoff Meeting 1 week from contract finalization September 23, 2005 Task 1. Draft Project Description 1 week from kickoff meeting September 30, 2005 City Review Period 2 weeks October 3- October 14, 2005 Task 2• Draft Initial Study (including optional tasks) 6 weeks from City approval of Project Description October 17 -November 28, 2005 City Review Period 2 weeks November 29 — December 9, 2005 Project Meeting to discuss MND vs. EIR End of City Review period December 12, 2005 Task 3• NOP Package Distribution 2 weeks from end of City review December 23, 2005 Public/Agency Scoping Period 30 calendar days December 27, 2005 -January 25, 2006 Task 3: Administrative Draft EIR 3 weeks from end of scoping January 27 -February 17, 2006 City Review Period 2 weeks February 20 -March 3, 2006 Task 4. Prepare Draft EIR/NOC/NOA 2 weeks from end of City review March 6 — March 17 2006 Public Review Period 45 calendar days March 21 -May 5, 2006 Task 5 Administrative Final EIR 3 weeks from end of review period May 8 -- May 26, 2006 City Review Period 2 weeks May 29 — June 9, 2006 Task 6 Final EIR 2 weeks from end of City review June 12 — June 23, 2006 5.0 Budget ECORP will provide the Scope of Work detailed in this proposal on a time and materials basis The cost for this work is provided in Table 5-1 Additional work will be performed based on the rates in Table 5-2 Attendance by the Project Manager at additional meetings would be $315, assuming a 3 -hour meeting. No travel costs would be charged to the City. ECORP Consulting, Inc. ENVIRONMENTAL CONSULTANTS 18 Table 5-1 Budget Summary Without Optional Tasks ECORP Consulting, Inc. ENVIRONMENTAL CONSULTANTS Table 5-2 Budget Summary for Optional Tasks Task 1 Kickoff/ Project Description Task 2 Draft Initial Study Task 3 NOP/ Admin Draft EIR Task 4 Draft EIR/ Notices Task 5 Admin Final EIR/Draft MMRP Task 6 Final EIR/Final MMRP Task 7 Meetings TOTAL Labor $2,000 $8,200 $7,100 $4,950 $4,600 $2,500 $2,800 $32,150 Other Direct Costs $100 $350 $950 $2,000 $550 $890 $0 $4,840 Subcontractors $0 $6,000 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $6,000 Total $2,050 $14,550 $7,450 $8,950 $4,650 $2,990 $2,800 $42,990 ECORP Consulting, Inc. ENVIRONMENTAL CONSULTANTS Table 5-2 Budget Summary for Optional Tasks Biological Resources Optional Task Cultural Resources Optional Task Labor $900 $4,400 Other Direct Costs $100 $100 Subcontractors $8,000 $0 Total $9,000 $4,500 Table 5-2 RATE SCHEDULE FOR PROFESSIONAL SERVICES' Principal $150.00 - 190.00 Program Manager $95 00 — 150 00 Senior Engineer $95 00-150 00 Senior Ecologist .. $95 00-150 00 Senior Scientist ... $85 00-150 00 Cultural Resource Specialist $75.00-130.00 Project Managers ..$80 00-150.00 Biologist $55 00-110 00 CAD / GIS / Software Specialist $60 00-95 00 Environmental Specialist $55 00-110 00 Lab Technician $45 00-90 00 Assistant Project Manager / Administrative Assistant $40 00-80 00 Word Processing / Production Coordinator $40 00-70 00 Expense Reimbursement/Other 1. Color copies, equipment and other direct expenses are reimbursed with a 14% administrative handling charge (excluding mileage and per diem) 2 Subcontractor expenses are reimbursed with a 12% administrative handling charge 3 Mileage is reimbursed at $0.41 per mile. 4 Per Diem, depending upon geography, may be charged where overnight stays are required 5 Expert Witness Testimony, including Depositions, are billed at time and a half. IRatees effective January 2005 and are subject to change. ECORP Consulting, inc. ENVIRONMENTAL CONSULTANTS Costing Assumptions • The City will provide copies of all technical and environmental documents for the project and all NOP comments at the kickoff meeting • It is assumed that three alternatives will be examined in the EIR (including the No Project Alternative) • The EIR will be prepared using technical and environmental reports provided by the Applicant The EIR will include the topics for which impacts were identified either as "potentially significant" or "less than significant with mitigation incorporated" in the Initial Study checklist a ECORP Consulting, Inc will use and rely upon the accuracy of reports, project files, maps, and digital data provided by the client ECORP Consulting, Inc assumes no responsibility for verifying the accuracy of such data or the consequences of reliance on such data • ECORP Consulting will print and distribute all copies of the EIR and notices a The City will provide a list of surrounding property owners. These owners will receive a Notice of Availability, stating that the EIR is available for review at the Planning Department and at the library. a ECORP and the City will develop a list of interested agencies and other interested parties These agencies/individuals will be mailed a complete copy of the EIR It is assumed that the list will contain no more than 10 addresses • ECORP will post the Notice of Availability and Notice of Determination at the County Clerk We have assumed that the City will arrange to have the notices published in the newspaper, and will pay all fees associated with newspaper publication and with County Clerk filing. ECORP Consulting, Inc. ENVIRONMENTAL CONSULTANTS 21 6.0 Insurance A sample insurance certificate follows this page. EC®RP Consulting, Inc. ENVIRONMENTAL CONSULTANTS 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 ■ JUL/13/20055ED 11 41 Al 07/13/2085 16 27 91678291.34 ECDRP CONSULTING ECi]RPGpNS P 001 PAGE 03/04 ,,. ACC2Fia, CERTIFICATE OF LIABILITY INSURANCE DATE (RiMlDDlyy)07105!2005 PRODUCER Gleeley, Renton & Associates P, 0 Box 12675 Oakland CA 54604-2675 510 465-3090 THIS CERT)FICATE IS ISSUED AS A MATTE11 DF INPDRMAT1DN ONLY AND CONFERS NO RIGIHTS UPON THE CERTIFICATE HOLDER., THIS CERT1F1CATE DOES NOT AMEND, EXTEND OR ALTER THE COVERAGE AFFORDED BY THE POLICIES BELOW INSURERS AFFORDING CDVISRAIII! mum) ECORP Consulting Southern California LLC 2260 Douglas Blvd , Suite 160 Roseville, CA 95651INsutien 1 INSURERI. United States Fidelity S. Guaranty INSURER a American Automatlie Ins Cu Mum G. Great American Assurance Co D INSURER E iw4, • ,.!„ar.V THE POLICIES OF INSURANCE LISTED BELOW HAVE BEEN ISSUED TO THE ANY REOUIREMENT TERM OR CONDITION OF ANY CONTRACT OR OTHaR MAY PERTAIN THE INSURANCE AFFORDED 8Y THE POLICIES DESCRIBED POUCIES AGGREGATE LIMITS SHOWN MAY HAve BEEN REDUCED PT PAID CLAIMS - INSURED NAMED ABOVE DOCUMENT WITH HEREIN IS SUBJECT POLI V E OTiff DATEIMWUD/YY1 FOR THS POLICY RESPECT TO WHICH TO ALL THE TERMS PolIC l•:klgnlitibN UATEJARAIDDrYY1_ PERIOD INDICATED NOTWTTMSTANDING THIS CE 11FIGATE MAY BE ISSUED OR EtCLUSIONS AND CONDITIONS OE SUCH ILSR IR A TYPE OPINIUIIANDII POLICY NUMBER LIMITS eaNsRu.DABILIIY X; CDRMAERCIALC?ENERALL71ABiLITY BK01517256 BA01661269 10101104 12131/04 10101106 12/3/105 EACH OCCURRENCE s1,000,000 MIRE DAMAGE IAny ane NV) 11.000,000 CLAMS MADE L : OCCUR MED GXP (Ahy 8110 • NI) 910,000 PE 1SOI AE. a ADv ROLM . M S1,000,000 LIMIT APPLIES PER- I POIIGY PI JEL7 rT toc GENERAL AGGREGATE 52,000,000 creNLAGGREEATE PIiODUCTS GOMP/OPAOS �— . • ` COMBINED SIMILE UMIT mEaaaeisterin s2;000,000 51,000,000 A I AUTOMD9ILE X I.VIBELITT I ANY Avro ALL OWNiiD AUTOS ACHE7ULW AUTOS 1HIRED AUTOS I NON-ONNEDAUTOS BODILY rNJURY (Pe' Pei,oil y ODDLY INJURY (Palnooldanl) IS _ PROPERTY DAMAGE (P9, nCCIdpnI) �,.-- 1.OARAGE �) LLABILRY ANY AUTDOTHER AUTO ONLY EA ACCIDENT ; THAN EA ADO_ .� AUTO ONLY AGC A A 1 excessLir,m.mr X I OCCUR E CLAIUS MADE •_ BK011117286 10101104 07101105 10/01105 0?1Q110G EACHOCCURRENCE 52,000,000 AGGREGATE 22,000 000 s HDEEDUCTIELE , RETENTION $ Y 1Nt I;TxTu. DTH �1 X ftpQy LIMITS I EA B WORKERS @OMPIEN9ATIDN AND EMPLOYARI LIABILITY WZP80923681 LEL EACH ACCIDENT f1 000 000 LEI DISEASE EA E MPLDYm x1.000 OQ0 I EL DISEASE POLICY LIMIT i LI 000,000 DTYIER Professional EDN5850312 .iab;lity 10101/04 10101/05 $1,000,000 per claim $2,000,000 anni aggr, DESCRIPTION DFEPBRATIDNS1LOCATIONIWIFICL6S+I:XDLu91OMS ADDED BY VIDDIRSEMENTAPECIALPROVISIONS Generar Liability policy excludes claims arising out of the performance of professional services, CERTIFICATE I40LDFJR DMONALMSURSD •INSURER LETTER CANCELLATION r.=mSAMPLE CERTIFICATE== SHOULD ANYDFfl EABOVEDESCRIBEDPOLICIESEECANCELLEDHEFORETRaEYRRATIDN LUTE THEREOF THE ISSUING INSURER WILL ENDEAVOR TOMAIL3D , DAYS wRr TEN NORCETOTHE CEITTWCATE HOLDER NAM ED TOTHELEFY, DM—FAILURE 'TO DOSOSHALL INPODS DD I.IGATIDNOPLIADILITYOF1WYNIND UPQN-TNLINSURER,1TSAGENTSOR 1§: PFIESENTATTvCC. AuTHD 2E0 REPRESENTATIVE l 1JAAa a ;A / �.•� APPENDIX A RESUMES 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 Anne Surdzial, AICP Project Manager ECORP Consulting, Inc. ENV1RO\MFNTAL CONSULTkNTS Summary Ms Surdzial is an environmental analyst with 15 years experience in the planning field She has prepared and managed the preparation of lSs1EAs and EIRs1EISs for a variety of projects subject to review under the CEQA and NEPA Much of her experience focuses on the environmental analysis of water, wastewater, and transportation infrastructure projects She has conducted socioeconomic, environmental justice, public services, transportation, and utilities impact analyses for a variety of federal, state, regional and local agencies, and private clients She is also experienced in land use planning and historic preservation issues and has worked for public planning departments Education B S , Environmental Science, University of California, Riverside Registrations, Certifications, and Affiliations • American Institute of Certified Planners (AICP), July 1994, Certificate No 11097 • Association of Environmental Professional CEQA workshops, updated annually • American Planning Association • Association of Environmental Professionals Professional Experience EIR for Bulldog Commons Development Project — City of Redlands Project Manager for an ElR for the development of a 3 -acre site into an apartment complex The Bulldog Commons development consists of 40 dwelling units in two, 2 -story buildings in an infill area in the City of Redlands near the University of Redlands As part of intersection improvements required to provide access to the project site, the Mill Creek Zanja channel was required to be re-routed This portion of the channel is listed on the National Register of Historic Places (NRNP) and the California Register of Historical Resources (CRHR), because it is the earliest remaining civil engineering project in southern California in addition to impacts to Cultural Resources related to the Zanja, hydrology and biological resources impacts were also key environmental issues ISIEA for Flood Control Improvements on Mission Zanja Creek -- City of Redlands. As Project Manager, responsible for an IS/EA for improvements to an approximately 500 foot segment of the Mission Zanja Creek, between 9th Street and 7th Street in the City of Redlands The project purpose is to provide flood protection to the downtown area of the City of Redlands Program EIR for the Crafton Hills College Master Plan — Pilot Engineering/San Bernardino Community College District Project Manager for an EIR for the Master Plan for Grafton Hills College, a community college located in Yucaipa, California The Master Plan provided for the expansion of the Anne Surdzial (Continued) Page 2 of 3 college infrastructure and facilities through 2025 Constraints analyses were also prepared for biological resources, archaeological resources, and paleontologic resources Third Party Review of Martin Ranch E1R — City of San Bernardino Project Manager and Lead Reviewer for third -party review of an EIR prepared by another consultant as an extension of the City of San Bernardino staff The EIR was prepared for the Martin Ranch project, a Planned Residential Development consisting of 342 single-family residential lots, two park sites, three water reservoir sites, and private streets on 352 8 acres The project site was in a hillside area and was subject to the City's Hillside Management Overlay District requirements The site was also in the General Plan Biological Resources Management Overlay District and Foothil Fire Zones Overlay District The proposed project and plans were reviewed to ensure consistency with the General Plan, Zoning, and Overlay Districts, the Screencheck Draft ERR and Technical Plans were reviewed for consistency and compliance with CEQA, and the Responses to Comments, MMRP, Findings, and Statement of Overriding Considerations were reviewed for compliance with CEQA Public hearings were also attended as support to City staff EIR for the Expansion of the Barstow Sanitary Landfill — County of San Bernardino. Project Manager for this EIR The County of San Bernardino planned to consolidate its landfill services into regional landfills supported by transfer stations to save landfill operating costs The Barstow Sanitary Landfill was selected as a regional landfill To serve the regional population previously served by multiple, smaller landfills, and to serve future populations, the County proposed to expand the Barstow Sanitary Landfill both vertically and horizontally An Initial Study, Environmental Impact Report, Mitigation Monitoring and Reporting Program and supporting technical studies were prepared for the landfill expansion Issues of concern included biological resources (desert tortoise, Mohave ground squirrel, sensitive plants), aesthetics traffic, noise, air quality, cultural resources, hazards and hazardous materials, and water quality Brea Canon Estates Specific Plan EIR, Orange County -- City of Brea As Project Manager, responsible for the EIR for a Specific Plan for the development of a 38 7 -acre parcel located along the west side of Brea Boulevard, west of the Orange (SR -57) Freeway in the City of Brea's Sphere of Influence The proposed project, to be known as Brea Canon Estates, would include development of 81 single-family residences in two neighborhoods, an open space area, and continued oil production facilities Visual Resources, Noise, Biological Resources, Air Quality, and Traffic Studies, Riverwalk Vista Specific Plan, Riverside, Riverside County -- Griffin Industries Provided overall Project Management for environmental studies provided to the City of Riverside in support of a Subsequent EIR for the Riverwalk Vista Specific Plan Also served as Technical Lead for the Visual Resources analysis for the project Griffin Industries proposed an alternative site plan for a site with an existing Specific Plan The proposed plan was for a 450 -unit single family residential development The City required the developer to submit technical studies in certain resource areas to compare the impacts of the previously -approved mixed land uses and the newly -proposed residential land uses The technical studies were completed on a fast-track basis to meet Planning Commission deadlines CEQA Documentation for the West Creek Specific Plan, Victorville, San Bernardino County — SunCal Project Manager for an Initial Study for the 400 -acre Specific Plan The proposed development included single-family residences, parks, a school site, and a trail CEQA Documentation for the Joshua Ridge Planned Community, Victorville, San Bernardino County - SunCal. Project Manager CEQA Documentation for 150 acres in Victorville The proposed development included single-family residences and open space Third -Party Review of Tentative Tract 16047 (Hover Property) — City of Brea Reviewed all CEQA documents related to this Tentative Tract to determine if a proposed change in a road alignment would Anne Surdzial (Continued) Page 3 of 3 require additional analysis, or if it was included as part of the scope of the original analysis All project documents were reviewed, including Initial Study, EIR, EIR Addendum, Findings, and Statement of Overriding Considerations The project was for 55 lots in the City's Hillside Development Area On -Call Master Services Agreement for Environmental Services - Yucaipa Valley Water District Program Manager for on-call environmental services for water and wastewater projects in the cities of Yucaipa and Calimesa with the Yucaipa Valley Water District Under this contract, responsible for determining the appropriate environmental documentation and studies to comply with CEQA and to obtain the appropriate environmental permits for YVWD projects Task orders completed under this on- call contract include the preparation and filing of categorical exemptions for small projects, the preparation of IS1MNDs for potable and non -potable pipelines and reservoirs, and construction monitoring Examples of projects completed under this contract include • Biology Support for Bryant Street Pipeline, Yucaipa Coordinated with California Department of Fish and Game, Regional Water Quality Control Board, U S Army Corps of Engineers, and U S Fish and Wildlife Service to determine biology requirements and permits for a pipeline and outfall • IS/MND and Permitting for a 30" Potable Water Pipeline, Yucaipa and Calimesa Prepared an ISIMND and associated permit applications for a new, 2 -mile 30" potable water pipeline, which would cross Wildwood Creek Coordinated with City of Yucaipa, who was proposing a new bridge at the pipeline location • ISIMND and Permitting for a 30" Potable Water Pipeline, Yucaipa. Prepared an ISIMND and associated permit applications for a new, 2 -mile, 30" potable water pipeline, which was proposed to cross Wilson Creek • ISIMND for Coussoulis Reservoir, Calimesa Prepared an ISIMND for a new 5 -million -gallon potable water reservoir on 5 acres in the City of Calimesa • Paleontological Resources Monitoring for Water Filtration Plant, Yucaipa Provided paleontological resources monitoring for construction of a water filtration plant A summary report was also provided o IS/MND for Chapman Heights RoadlSand Canyon Road Non -Potable Water Pipelines, Yucaipa Project Manager for the IS/MND for the installation of non -potable water pipelines in 2 roadways in the City of Yucaipa The IS/MND was prepared on an expedited schedule to meet construction deadlines • MND Addendum for Non -Potable Water Pipeline Extensions, Calimesa and Yucaipa. Project Manager for an MND Addendum for the extension of the non -potable water system by approximately 3 miles The MND Addendum was prepared on an expedited schedule to meet construction deadlines o MND Addendum for Non -Potable Pipeline to Water Filtration Plant, Yucaipa. Project Manager for an MND Addendum, which examined a new route for the incoming pipeline to a new water filtration plant The MND Addendum was prepared on an expedited schedule to meet construction deadlines ISIMND for the Extension of Chapman Heights Road, Yucaipa -- City of Yucaipa. As Project Manager, responsible for this IS, which examined extension of Chapman Heights Road from the western boundary of the Chapman Heights Planned Development, westerly to Sand Canyon Road Evelyn N. Chandler Cultural Resources Manager ECORP Consulting, Inc. F VIRON\1hNrAi CO\C!'lTANTS Summary Ms Chandler has over 13 years of experience in cultural resources management and has participated in and supervised all aspects of archaeological fieldwork, Including survey, test excavation, data recovery, and construction monitoring She has conducted numerous evaluations of archaeological sites and historic architectural resources for eligibility to the National Register of Historic Places (NRNP) and California Register of Historical Resources (CRHR) and is well versed in impact assessment and development of mitigation measures She has extensive familiarity with issues related to compliance with cultural resources requirements of the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) and Sections 106 and 110 of the National Historic Preservation Act (NHPA) She has recorded and mapped hundreds of prehistoric and historic archaeological sites and has identified and analyzed thousands of prehistoric and historic artifacts Ms Chandler regularly assists clients with consultation with Native American groups and organizations as well as with the State Historic Preservation Officers (SHPOs) Education B A Anthropology/Sociology, University of Redlands, Redlands, California B A , Political Science, University of Redlands, Redlands, California Professional Organizations/Associations • National Trust for Historic Preservation • Society for American Archaeology o Society for California Archaeology Relevant Experience Cultural Resources Survey of a 65 -Acre Griffin Industries Residential Development in Southeast Redlands, San Bernardino County, California Project Manager for archival research, survey of a 65 - acre project area in the City of Redlands, recordation of a historic -period residence and a historic -period water pipeline, and evaluation of the residence and pipeline for eligibility to the CRHR and the Register of Historic and Scenic Resources of the City of Redlands DPR 523 forms and a technical report were also prepared EIR and Cultural Resources Survey of a 3 8 -acre Bulldog Commons Development in Redlands, San Bernardino County, California Project Manager for for archival research, survey of a 3 8 -acre parcel, recordation of a historic -period residence, and assessment of potential effects of the proposed project to the Mill Creek Zanja, an NRHP-listed irrigation feature dating to the Spanish Period The residence was evaluated for eligibility to the CRHR and the Register of Historic and Scenic Resources of the City of Redlands DPR 523 forms and a technical report were also prepared Prepared the Cultural Resources Section of the EIR for the development Evelyn N Chandler (Continued) Page 2 of 2 IS/EA for Flood Control Improvements on Mission Zanja Creek -- City of Redlands Cultural Resources technical lead for an IS/EA for improvements to an approximately 500 -foot segment of the Mission Zanja Creek, between 91h Street and 7 h Street in the City of Redlands The project purpose is to provide flood protection to the downtown area of the City of Redlands EIR for the Expansion of the Barstow Sanitary Landfill — County of San Bernardino. Cultural Resources technical lead for this EIR The County of San Bernardino planned to consolidate its landfill services into regional landfills supported by transfer stations to save landfill operating costs The Barstow Sanitary Landfill was selected as a regional landfill To serve the regional population previously served by multiple, smaller landfills, and to serve future populations, the County proposed to expand the Barstow Sanitary Landfill both vertically and horizontally An Initial Study, Environmental Impact Report, Mitigation Monitoring and Reporting Program and supporting technical studies were prepared for the landfill expansion Historic Resources Evaluation of the First Protestant Reformed Church of Redlands, Parsonage, and Schoolhouse, San Bernardino County, California -- Boys and Girls Club of Redlands Project Manager responsible for oversight of archival research, field recordation, and CRHR evaluation of a historic -period church, parsonage, and schoolhouse in Redlands, San Bernardino County in support of construction of a new Boys and Girls Club facility Also reviewed technical report and DPR forms and coordinated project requirements with the City of Redlands Cultural Resources Reports for the Proposed Park N" Ride Facility, Crestline, San Bernardino County, California -- San Bernardino County Department of Public Works . Cultural Resources Task Leader responsible for oversight of the preparation of a Historic Property Survey Report, Archaeological Survey Report, and Historic Architectural Survey Report for a proposed park and ride facility in Crestline, California All reports were prepared under contract to the County of San Bernardino Department of Public Works in accordance with Caltrans guidelines Cultural resources sections of the Initial Study were also prepared Cultural Resources Survey of the West Creek Planned Community, Victorville, San Bernardino County, California — SunCal Companies. Project Manager for cultural resources survey of 400 acres in Victorville in support of CEQA compliance Tasks included a records search, field survey, site evaluation, and preparation of site records, technical report, and cultural resources sections of the project IS During the study, portions of three linear historic -age resources, consisting of a road and two transmission lines, were evaluated for eligibility to the CRHR Potential impacts to cultural resources from the proposed development were also assessed and mitigation measures were provided Cultural Resources Study for the Proposed Establishment of Nature Hiking Trails in Oak Glen, San Bernardino County, California — County of San Bernardino Special District Department. Cultural Resources Task Leader responsible for oversight of the archaeological record search of a 26 6 -acre project area where nature trails, picnic areas, an outdoor amphitheater, and a restroom facility area proposed All work was conducted under contract to the County of San Bernardino Special Districts Department Cultural resources sections of the Initial Study were also prepared and recommendations for survey and site evaluations were also provided Cultural Resources Survey in support of Construction of a 38 -Acre Ion Communities Residential Development in Redlands, San Bernardino County, California Project Manager responsible for oversight of the field survey of 38 acres in Redlands, San Bernardino County, California for construction of a new housing development Also reviewed the technical report and the site record and evaluation of a previously unrecorded historic archaeological site for eligibility to the CRHR Donald R. Mitchell Inland Empire Operations Manager Principal Biologist ECORP Consulting, Inc @11 IRo .MENTA . t ONSI'LTANTS Summary Mr Mitchell has 18 years of applied and research experience in the field of environmental science, with particular emphasis on wildlife assessments, impact analysis, and project management He has extensive experience in conducting biological studies, focused threatened and endangered species surveys, sensitive habitat surveys, and integrating the Graphic Information System (GIS) into environmental studies, as well as preparing biological reports, mitigation and monitoring plans, Biological Assessments (BAs), Initial Studies (lSs), Environmental Assessments (EAs), and Environmental impact Reports (EIRs) He specializes in designing, budgeting, and managing cost effective biological studies for large, complex, and controversial projects He has also conducted or managed surveys for the Stephens' kangaroo rat, San Bernardino Merriam's kangaroo rat, California gnatcatcher, desert tortoise, Mohave ground squirrel, San Joaquin kit fox, California red -legged frog, arroyo southwestern toad, unarmored threespine stickleback, and a wide variety of Mojave desert and southern California terrestrial plant and wildlife species Education M S , Zoology, Northwestern State University of Louisiana, Natchitoches B S , Biology, University of Redlands, California Registrations, Certifications, and Affiliations • California Department of Fish and Game Scientific Collecting Permit • Named Surveyor on CDFG MOU for Mohave Ground Squirrel Trapping ♦ The Nature Conservancy • National Military Fish and Wildlife Association (Associate) • The Wildlife Society ♦ American Society of Mammalogists Selected Professional Experience Biological Services On -Call Contract — California Department of Transportation District 8 Program manager for a two year on-call biological services contract for the Department of Transportation District 8 (includes all of San Bernardino and Riverside Counties) Under this program, the consultant/contractor essentially serves as an extension of District 8 biological services staff, performing habitat assessments, focused surveys for sensitive species, jurisdictional waters delineations, biological monitoring and preparing Natural Environment Studies, Biological Assessments, delineation reports, and other environmental documents for a wide range of Caltrans projects Managed and conducted studies for over 40 task orders and completed them on time and under budget Tasks completed included Donald Mitchell (Continued) Page 2 of 3 • Conducted protocol Mohave ground squirrel trapping study on three 100 -trap grids (900 trap -days prior to positive survey result) along State Route 395 • Conducted protocol Mohave ground squirrel trapping study on five 100 -trap grids (7500 trap - days) along State Route 138 • Conducted sensitive plant surveys along nine miles of State Route 395 • Conducted Zone of Influence surveys for desert tortoise along 16 miles of State Route 138 • Performed desert tortoise worker education and construction monitoring along Interstate 10 in eastern Coachella Valley • Performed desert tortoise worker education and construction monitoring along Interstate 15 between Stateline and Baker • Conducted trapping for white -eared pocket mouse along State Route 138 • Performed habitat assessments and/or protocol -level trapping for San Bernardino Merriam's kangaroo rat (SBKR) near the 1-15/SR 210 interchange • Performed SBKR and/or Stephens' kangaroo rat habitat assessments and protocol surveys at multiple location along SR 91, SR 74, SR 79, and Interstate 10 • Performed California gnatcatcher surveys near the SR 91/Green River Road interchange • Performed least Bell's vireo and southwestern willow flycatcher surveys at multiple locations along State Route 79 and State Route 215 • Performed yellow -legged frog surveys along interstate 15 near Mountain Pass • Performed jurisdictional waters delineations at multiple locations along State Route 91, State Route 60 and Interstate 215 • Performed vernal pool, freshwater shrimp, and sensitive plant surveys at two sites along Interstate 215 • Prepared Natural Environment Studies and Biological Assessments for numerous projects in District 8 • Provided peer review of sections of the EIR for the replacement of the Big Bear Dam bridge Biological Reconnaissance Survey for CalMat (Vulcan Materials) Company, Upland, Los Angeles County Performed reconnaissance surveys for biological resources and sensitive species for road widening project Species of concern in the area included San Bernardino kangaroo rat, California gnatcatcher, and several rare plants Santa Ana River Levee Project, Norton Air Force Base, California Performed wildlife surveys, including small mammal trapping (San Bernardino Merriam's kangaroo rat [prior to listing]) large mammal and herpetofauna surveys, and surveys for threatened, endangered, and sensitive species Prepared a biological assessment summarizing the results of field surveys to aid the base in developing a future course of action concerning completing construction of a levee in the Santa Ana River Biological Studies for the SR-60!Nason Street Interchange Improvement Project, Moreno Valley, California., Parsons Brinckerhoff Quade & Douglas for the City of Moreno Valley Project manager for biological studies in support of the preparation of environmental documents for the SR-60/Nason Street Interchange Improvement Project General biological surveys were conducted for vegetation and wildlife Focused (protocol -Level) surveys were conducted for several sensitive species including Stephens' kangaroo rat, least Bell's vireo, southwestern willow flycatcher, and burrowing owl Formal delineation of waters under the jurisdiction of the California Department of Fish and Game and U S Army Corps of Engineers was conducted Pilot Solar Energy Project, Patton State Hospital, San Bernardino, CA — State of California, Real Estate Services Division — Department of General Services Task Manager for Biological Resources for an environmental constraints analysis for the construction of a Pilot project to install solar panels over a parking area at Patton State Hospital Donau[ Mitchell (Continued) Page 3 of 3 Colton Landfill Revegetation, San Bernardino County — NORCAL Project manager for the preparation and implementation of a revegetation plan to mitigate impacts to riparian habitat occupied by least Bell's vireo Least Bell's vireo habitat along the Santa Ana river was removed to facilitate the installation of a leachate barrier to protect groundwater and the river near the Colton landfill To mitigate these impacts, the County implemented a revegetation and monitoring program to restore and enhance cottonwood willow riparian forest and southern willow scrub along the edge of the river Environmental Impact Statement (EIS)! Environmental impact Report (EIR) for the construction of the Southern California Edison (SCE) Devers — Palo Verde No 2 Project — Aspen Environmental Group for the California Public Utilities Commission Project Manager for Biology -California portion The project consists of the construction of a 230 mile 500 kV transmission line from the Devers Substation near Palm Springs to the Palo Verde/Hassayampa area in Arizona In addition, SCE proposes 47 miles of upgrades to four existing 230 kV Innes from the Devers to San Bernadino and Vista Substations near the City of San Bernardino Stephens' Kangaroo Rat Surveys and GIS Development for the March Air Force Base, California SKR Preserve - The Nature Conservancy Under contract to The Nature Conservancy, managed three years of Stephens' kangaroo rat surveys and GIS development for the 1,000 -acre Stephens' kangaroo rat preserve The project made innovative use of off-the-shelf GIS software products for data management and report generation The goal of the project was to develop a prescribed burn regime for the preserve that would result in a plant species composition best suited to the needs of the endangered Stephens' kangaroo rat and other native species inhabiting the preserve Basewide Survey and BA for Stephens' Kangaroo Rat - Marine Corps Base, Camp Pendleton, California. Managed the performance of a basewide survey for the federal -listed endangered Stephens' kangaroo rat (Dipodomys stephensr) on Marine Corps Base, Camp Pendleton A BA was prepared to evaluate the potential impacts of military training and support activities on the Stephens' kangaroo rat and included a mitigation/management plan for the species The surveys and BA also analyzed the potential impacts of the management plan on other sensitive species on the base The survey and BA supported formal consultation with the U S Fish and Wildlife Service under Section 7 of the Endangered Species Act Ecological Baseline Survey - March Air Force Base, California Supervised and conducted biological surveys and prepared an Ecological Baseline Survey report in support of the preparatron of an Ecological Risk Assessment for Installation Restoration Program activities Studies included surveys for the endangered Stephens' kangaroo rat, sensitive plants and invertebrates, as well as general vegetation and wildlife surveys STEPHEN JON MONTGOMERY Wildlife Biologist SJM Biological Consultants U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service Permit TE745541-8 EDUCATION Master of Science, Biology/Ecology, 1976, Utah State University Thesis Rodent -Habitat Relationships in Great Basin Desert Shrub Communities Bachelor of Science, Wildlife Biology, 1970, Utah State University EXPERIENCE Owner, Principal Consultant SJM Biological Consultants 1983 to Present Manage and conduct field surveys, analyze data and prepare reports for diverse types of biological studies, including• rare/endangered/sensitive species studies, environmental impact reports; development suitability studies, project monitoring, biological inventories Prepare proposals, determine equipment and budget requirements, manage projects and technical staff, meet with municipal, state and federal agencies, and present findings at meetings SELECTED RELEVANT PROJECTS Conducted Habitat Assessment and Trapping Studies for Federally Endangered San Bernardino and Stephens' Kangaroo Rats for vanous development and public works projects in San Timoteo Canyon, Redlands, and unincorporated Riverside and San Bernardino Counties — ECORP Consulting, Redlands, California 2004-2005 Conducted protocol -level trapping studies for the State -listed (threatened) Mohave ground squirrel at multiple development sites in Victorvilie and Apple Valley - ECORP Consulting, Redlands, California 2005 Conducted trapping studies for Mohave ground squirrels at the Air Force Flight Test Center, Edwards Air Force Base, CA - ECORP Consulting, Redlands, California 2005 Conducted Trapping Studies for Federally Endangered San Bernardino and Stephens' Kangaroo Rats For Various CalTrans Projects, in San Bernardino and Riverside Counties, Calif For Chambers Group, Redlands, California 2003-2004. Stephen J Montgomery - Resume Developed Post -construction Habitat Restoration Methods and Specifications for the Federally Endangered San Bernardino Kangaroo Rat for Contract 3-4 (Santa Ana River Area) of the Metropolitan Water District (MWD) Inland Feeder Waterline Project For P&D Consultants Orange, Calif Worked with MWD staff and U.S Fish and Wildlife Service biologists m developing specifications for sand grain sizes, as well as for methods and configurations of sand deposition m the construction area for Contract 3- 4 These methods were designed to maximize future use of the construction area by the SBKR 2001- 2004 Conducted Trapping Study for Federally Endangered San Bernardino Kangaroo Rat, Stephens' Kangaroo Rat, Los Angeles Pocket Mouse and other California sensitive small mammals at Lake Elsinore, California For Glenn Lukos & Associates 2003 Assisted In Development of Biological Assessment for the Federally Endangered San Bernardino Kangaroo Rat, for the 7 Oaks Dam Project, San Bernardino County, California For MEC Analytical Systems. Carlsbad, California Analyzed impacts of operation of 7 Oaks Dam on SBKR, assisted in analyzing alternative habitat management and enhancement schemes for this species 1999-2000. Conducted trapping and habitat affinity studies for the Federally Endangered San Bernardino Kangaroo Rat (SBKR) at vanous localities in the Santa Ana River, San Bernardino County, Cahforma, for U S Army Corps of Engineers Seven Oaks Dam project For MEC Analytical Systems, Carlsbad, California Assisted m study design, trapped SBKR at 14 sites, and participated in SBKR habitat preferences study 1999-2000 Conducted trapping and habitat assessment surveys for the Federally Endangered San Bernardino Kangaroo Rat (SBKR) at vanous localities in the Santa Ana River, Lytle Creek and Cajon Creek Washes, San Bernardino County, California For Sunwest Materials (Ontario, Calif ), CalMat Corporation (Riverside, Calif), and the Chambers Group (Irvine, Calif) Trapped and mapped habitat for SBKR rn alluvial fan scrub habitats m sandy wash habitats in the three river systems mentioned above 1998-2000 Relocated Stephens' Kangaroo Rats (SKR) Residing in the Construction Zone of the Contract 7/8 of the Metropolitan Water District Inland Feeder Pipeline For P&D Consultants (Orange, Calif) and Metropolitan Water District of Southern California (Los Angeles, Calif.) Trapped and relocated SKR to artificial burrow systems m nearby suitable habitat at the Cahforma Department of Fish and Game San Jacinto Wildlife Area Riverside County, California Monitored. relocated SKR in 1998 and 1999, and monitored SKR recolonrzation of rehabilitated construction zone m 2000 (on-going) Directed and Conducted Intensive Trapping Survey for the Federally Endangered Pacific Pocket Mouse at Camp Pendleton Manne Corps Base Intensive team trapping effort to determine presence/absence of PPM m several previously unsurveyed ranges of Camp Pendleton 1998, on-going Mapped Occupied San Bernardino Memam's Kangaroo Rat (SBKR) Habitat in Portions of the Metropolitan Water District Inland Feeder Pipeline Alignment, in alluvial fan scrub habitats m the Santa Ana River and City Creek P&D Technologies Orange, Calif Conducted trappmg studies and completed maps of occupied habitat for SBKR along the Inland Feeder waterline nght-of-way 1994-2000 Stephen J Montgomery — Resume -2- Conducted Required Studies for the Metropolitan Water Distract Inland Feeder Waterhne Right -of -Way P&D Technologies, Orange, Calif Conducted required field studies for sensitive small -mammal species, assisted in the development of a preliminary biological assessment of impacts to San Bernardino Kangaroo Rat, mitigation work for Stephens' kangaroo rats, and others July 1994-1996 Conducted Field Studies Required for the Metropolitan Water District Inland Feeder Waterline Project, on the Federally Endangered Stephens' Kangaroo Rat and alluvial fan scrub inhabiting San Bernardino kangaroo rat, in the area of the Santa Ana River, San Jacinto Wildlife Area and San Tnmoteo Canyon. For P&D Environmental Services, Orange, Calif Conducted trapping studies, mapped habitat, assessed impacts of proposed project, developed mitigation strategies, prepared portion of Biological Assessment for San Bernardino kangaroo rat 1994-95 CERTIFICATIONS/PERMITS U 5 Fish and Wildlife Service Permit to trap and handle the Federally Endangered San Bernardino Kangaroo Rat California Department of Fish and Game Memorandum of Understanding to trap and handle the California State Sensitive (Federally Endangered) San Bernardino Kangaroo Rat U S Fish and Wildlife Service Permit to trap, tag and handle the Federally Endangered Pacific Pocket Mouse U S Fish and Wildlife Service Permit to trap, handle, and translocate the Federally Endangered Stephens' Kangaroo Rat U S Fish and Wildlife Service Permit to conduct field studies of Federally Endangered Yuma Clapper Rail Formerly held USFWS Permit to trap, handle and conduct radio telemetry studies on this species U S Fish and Wildlife Service Permit to conduct field surveys for the Federally Endangered Amargosa Vole U S. Fish and Wildhfe Service Permit to conduct field surveys for the Federally Threatened California Gnatcatcher (as independent investigator on Shana Dodd=s USFWS Permit) California Department of Fish and Game Memorandum of Understanding to trap, handle and translocate the State Threatened (Federally Endangered) Stephens' Kangaroo Rat California Department of Fish and Game Memorandum of Understanding to trap and handle the California State Sensitive (Federally Endangered) Pacific Pocket Mouse Stephen J Montgomery — Resume -3- ientl'c ' esources ssociate VALORIE L. THOMPSON, PH.D. PRINCIPAL Dr Thompson has over fifteen years of experience in environmental planning, air quality studies, air tomes emission evaluations, health nsk assessments, process safety management, hazard and operability studies, off-site consequence analysis, and atmosphenc dispersion modeling and is the founder of Scientific Resources Associated She has managed numerous environmental planning, air quality, and risk assessment projects, including preparation of the Application for Certification for a proposed new natural gas-fired power plant, evaluation of nsks associated with hazardous waste sites, and assessment of air emissions and air taxies nsks from manufacturing facilities, oil and gas processing facilities, chlonne repackaging facilities, incineration projects, and cogeneration facilities Dr Thompson has also assisted government clients in the development of air emission inventories and compliance strategies for large military bases Additionally, she has conducted research in atmospheric dispersion and enhanced oil recovery EDUCATION Ph D , Chemical Engineering, Purdue University, 1986 M S , Chemical Engineering, Purdue University, 1982 B.S , Chemistry, Eastern Michigan University, 1980 PROFESSIONAL REGISTRATIONS/AFFILIATIONS Young Professional Award, Woodward -Clyde Consultants, 1991 Air and Waste Management Association American Institute of Chemical Engineers Small Woman -Owned Business Enterpnse/Disadvantaged Business Enterpnse Certification Caltrans CT -030697 California Department of General Services Small Business Certification #0019779 PROFESSIONAL EXPERIENCE CEQA/NEPA Air Quality Analyses EIR for Bulldog Commons Development Project -- City of Redlands As a subcontractor to ECORP Consulting, prepared air quality analysis for an EIR for the development of a 3 -acre site into an apartment complex The Bulldog Commons development consists of 40 dwelling units in two, 2 -story buildings in an infill area in the City of Redlands near the University of Redlands Dr. Valorie L Thompson Page 2 ienlic Resources Associate Air Quality Analysis -- Yucaipa Valley Water DistrictxPdoject— Yucaipa Calimesa As a subcontractor to ECORP Consulting, prepared quality analyses for the construction and operation of several potable and non potable water pipeline projects Air Quality Analysis — Sugarbush Residential Development. In support of the Negative Declaration, Dr Thompson prepared the Air Quality Analysis for a proposed 60 -residence development located in northern San Diego County, California The project included an evaluation of construction emissions, including diesel particulate, and operational impacts associated with traffic accessing the development The project also included conducting a risk screening analysis of the diesel emissions associated with both construction and operational traffic Air Quality Analysis — Crestlake Residential Development. Dr Thompson prepared the Air Quality Analysis for a proposed residential development located in Alpine, California. The project included an evaluation of construction emissions, including diesel particulate, and operational impacts associated with traffic accessing the development. The project also included conducting a risk screening analysis of the diesel emissions associated with both construction and operational traffic to address potential risks to existing residences near the site Dr. Thompson also assisted in the identification and assessment of feasible mitigation measures to mitigate potential impacts Air Quality Analysis --- The Bridges at Rancho Santa Fe. Dr Thompson prepared the Air Quality Analysis and Air Quality Technical Report for a residential development located in north San Diego County The analysis included evaluating construction and operational impacts associated with the project Air Quality Evaluation — San Elmo Ridge Development Dr Thompson prepared the air quality evaluation for a proposed residential development in North San Diego County. The project involved estimating emissions from construction during four construction phases, and assisting the client in evaluating their options for phasing construction and use of heavy equipment to mitigate potential impacts Air Quality Analysis and Risk Evaluation — Science Research Park, UCSD Dr Thompson prepared the air quality anlaysis and risk evaluation for a proposed Science Research Park development at the University of California, San Diego. The project involved estimating amounts of air toxics that could be released on a routine basis from the facility due to normal operations of the facility The project also involved estimating whether the chemical usage is acceptable from a health risk standpoint